The Best Store-Bought Pistachio Ice Cream Brands Worth Your Money

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. See our disclosure policy.

If you are a fan of pistachio ice cream flavor, you will agree that the store-bought pistachio ice cream is easier than ever compared to making it homemade.

Pistachio ice cream is a tasty treat that you can enjoy it is our favorite flavor too. Pistachio ice cream is loved by many for its creamy texture and nutty taste.

The Best Store-Bought Pistachio Ice Cream Brands Worth Your Money 0

Anyway, not all pistachio ice creams have the same quality. And with that how can you choose the best store-bought pistachio ice creams from so many different brands?

We’ll tell you about our favorite for the best pistachio ice cream in this article.

Key Takeaways

  • Van Leeuwen Sicilian Pistachio French Ice Cream is recommended by pistachio lovers for its incredible flavor and strong pistachio flavor.
  • Ben & Jerry’s Pistachio Pistachio Ice Cream is rich and creamy with whole pistachios, and it is made with non-GMO ingredients and cage-free eggs.
  • Talenti Pistachio Gelato offers a decadent and rich flavor, smooth and creamy texture, and it is gluten-free and kosher certified with environmentally friendly packaging.
  • Haagen-Dazs Pistachio Ice Cream combines roasted pistachio nuts and sweet cream for an exotic flavor and creamy texture, allowing the natural flavors to shine through.

Which is The 10 Best Store-Bought Pistachio Ice Cream Brand?

There are several factors to consider when selecting the best pistachio ice cream brand you can buy at your local grocery store.

The quality of the ingredients is the first thing to consider. Among others, using high-quality ingredients, free of preservatives or artificial flavors, is important.

Second, the flavor should be rich and creamy. Finally, the texture of the ice cream should be thick and smooth.

These are the best store-bought pistachio ice cream brands that you can consider if you never tried before.

10. Tillamook Creamery California Pistachio Ice Cream

tillamook creamery california pistachio ice cream store-bought via 501

We love the thick but soft consistency of this Tillamook pistachio ice cream.

Even though it’s already perfect, pistachio ice cream can be served with chocolate sauce and shortbread cookies.

9. Graeter’s Pistachio Ice Cream

graeters pistachio ice cream store-bought via 501

Graeter’s pistachio is a pistachio-flavored confection with a vanilla cream flavor. Thus it’s a favorite among pistachio fans.

This dense, creamy ice cream is flavored with pistachios and sweet vanilla cream. This ice cream is a goldmine for pistachio fans.

It is available only for a few weeks each year or until the supplies run out. You can purchase this rare flavor online or in your local scoop shop.

8. McConnell’s Fine Ice Creams – Pistachio & Almond Biscotti Ice Cream

mcconnells fine ice creams pistachio almond biscotti ice cream store-bought via 501

McConnell’s Fine Ice Cream has added a new seasonal item to its menu: Pistachio and Almond Biscotti Ice Cream.

This fine pistachio ice cream is made with milk, pistachio butter, and crumbled almond biscotti.

7. Trader Joe’s Pistachio Gelato

trader joes pistachio gelato store-bought via 501

We can immediately identify the flavor as pistachio when it comes to Trader Joe’s.

It’s sweet and nutty but not overly sweet. The pistachios are evenly distributed throughout the gelato and blend together so well that we cannot imagine a better ratio of nuts to dairy.

Coconut oil is the main ingredient, and it gives the gelato a texture that is similar to ice cream but thicker.

You should eat this gelato when it’s cold but not frozen.

Trader Joe’s pistachio gelato is a very tasty ice cream and we are sure you would happily purchase it again and again.

6. Blue Bell Pistachio Almond Ice Cream

blue bell pistachio almond ice cream store-bought via 501

Blue Bell’s ice cream has a base of pistachio and is accented by pieces of crunchy, roasted almonds.

If you do not have allergies, it is a great flavor for you. You won’t regret trying it and may find your new favorite.

5. Van Leeuwen Sicilian Pistachio French Ice Cream

van leeuwen sicilian pistachio french ice cream store-bought via 501

This ice cream uses high-quality ingredients in small batches to satisfy your sweet craving. And the pistachios used are imported from Bronte on Mount Etna, Italy.

Also, The International Slow Food Institute has certified these pistachios, which are renowned for their flavor and fragrance!

Why French ice cream? You must call it French ice Cream when you use double the amount of egg yolks than standard ice cream. And that is why.

This Pistachio ice cream is made with ingredients such as cream, milk and cane sugar. It also contains egg yolks, sea salt, and Sicilian pistachios.

The pistachio flavor is strong and satisfying, making it the closest you can get to pistachio gelato in a store-bought option.

Key Features:

  • Brand: Van Leeuwen
  • Flavor: Sicilian Pistachio
  • Size: 14 fluid ounces
  • No hydrogenated fats or high fructose corn syrup
  • No bleached or bromated flour
  • No synthetic nitrates or nitrites


  • Incredible flavor
  • Creamy and thick consistency
  • Strong pistachio flavor
  • Nutty aftertaste
  • Recommended by pistachio lovers
  • Closest to pistachio gelato


  • Some found it overly salty
  • Limited number of actual pistachio nuts in the container

4. Baskin-Robbins Pistachio Almond Ice Cream

baskin robbins pistachio almond ice cream store-bought via 501

Baskin-Robbins has been a tradition in ice cream for decades.

This iconic shop has something for everyone, from delicious flavors to interesting treats. This is our favorite ice cream store while waiting to see a movie or on grocery trips.

Some branches sell pistachio ice cream with roasted almonds in it. It isn’t available everywhere, as it’s not a compulsory flavor.

3. Ben & Jerry’s Pistachio Pistachio Ice Cream

ben jerrys pistachio pistachio ice cream store-bought via 501

Ben & Jerry’s pistachio ice cream was introduced in 1988 and had pistachios added as a filler in it.

It is cool and smooth. This gluten-free product uses natural flavors and has been hard to find recently.

This is the perfect treat for those who are in the mood for green store-bought ice cream brand.

The subtle play of salty sweetness in each scoop is a testament to the careful balance of flavors in this classic Ben & Jerry’s creation. With no artificial flavors or colors, this ice cream delivers a truly authentic pistachio experience.

Key Features:

  • Pint size: 16 oz
  • Non-GMO ingredients
  • Cage-free eggs
  • Fairtrade Certified ingredients
  • Certified Kosher


  • Rich and creamy texture
  • Loaded with whole pistachios
  • No artificial flavors or colors
  • Made with non-GMO ingredients and cage-free eggs
  • Certified Kosher


  • May contain too many nuts for some individuals
  • Limited availability in some areas
  • May be more expensive compared to other store-bought options

2. Talenti Pistachio Gelato

talenti pistachio gelato store-bought via 501

This flavor is Pacific Coast Pistachio. Talenti is known for using Italian words to promote their Italian gelato (Mediterranean Mint, Coffee Chocolate Chip, and Roman Raspberry to name a few). Still, Pacific Coast Pistachios do exist and are used in the pint.

The pistachio base and pieces are a complex mix of colors. The gelato is soft and has a pistachio taste.

The pistachio flavor is sweeter but still not overly sweet. The nut pieces were generously distributed throughout the pint.

This ice cream’s pistachios are soft, unlike other brands of ice cream we have tried. This ice cream is ideal for those who want a sweet but not overly sweet dessert with a nutty flavor.

This is a good option for gelato lovers who are looking for a best store-bought pistachio flavor.

Key Features:

  • Size: 1 pint
  • Gluten-free and OU-D Kosher Certified
  • Crafted with non-GMO ingredients
  • No high fructose corn syrup
  • Made with 100 percent Recycled Plastic


  • Decadent and rich flavor
  • Made with real ingredients
  • Smooth, creamy, and crunchy texture
  • Gluten-free and kosher certified
  • Environmentally friendly packaging


  • May be more expensive than other store-bought options
  • Limited availability in some areas
  • May not be suitable for those with nut allergies

1. Haagen-Dazs Pistachio Ice Cream

haagen dazs pistachio ice cream store-bought via 501

Häagen Dazs has one of the most delicious pistachio ice creams available in the United States. It is full of flavor and contains roasted Californian pistachios.

When removing the lid, we can see that there are already a lot of pistachios on top. As we dig in, the pistachios are immediately noticeable.

Each spoonful contains a lot of pistachios. It almost tastes as if the base has some pistachio flavor in it.

It’s a pint of interesting pistachio-flavored ice cream. You will be greeted by a sweet, creamy, fresh ice cream, followed by pistachio pieces.

You can order this best store-bought pistachio ice creams quickly and easily from Amazon.

Key Features:

  • Brand: HÄAGEN-DAZS
  • Flavor: Pistachio Ice Cream
  • Size: 14 oz
  • Ingredients: Roasted pistachio nuts, sweet cream, cream, cane sugar, skim milk, egg yolks
  • Gluten-free
  • Milk and cream from cows not treated with growth hormone rBST


  • Exotic flavor combining roasted pistachio nuts and sweet cream
  • Made with high-quality ingredients for a creamy texture
  • No artificial taste, allowing the natural flavors to shine through


  • Some customers find it expensive
  • Some customers feel there could be more pistachios in the ice cream.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I Find Store-Bought Pistachio Ice Cream That Is Suitable for Vegans or Those With Dietary Restrictions?

You can find store-bought pistachio ice cream suitable for vegan or dietary restrictions. There are vegan alternatives and allergen-free options available. You can also explore flavor alternatives and check ingredient sourcing for your needs.

What Is the Average Price Range for Store-Bought Pistachio Ice Cream?

Store-bought pistachio ice cream can range from $4 to $10 per pint, depending on the brand and quality. Popular brands like Haagen-Dazs and Ben & Jerry’s offer specialty flavors, diverse packaging options, and detailed nutritional information.

Are There Any Store-Bought Pistachio Ice Cream Brands That Offer Organic or All-Natural Options?

Looking for store-bought pistachio ice cream with organic or all-natural options? Some brands offer these choices, perfect for those with dietary restrictions. Check out the price range to find one that fits your budget.

Can You Recommend Any Store-Bought Pistachio Ice Cream Brands That Are Known for Their Sustainability Practices?

You’ll find store-bought pistachio ice cream brands known for sustainability practices. They offer vegan options, cater to dietary restrictions, and fall within a reasonable price range. Organic/natural options are also available.

Are There Any Store-Bought Pistachio Ice Cream Brands That Offer Unique Flavor Combinations or Variations, Such as Pistachio With Chocolate or Pistachio With Salted Caramel?

Looking for unique ice cream flavors and gourmet options? Store-bought pistachio ice cream brands offer delicious combinations like pistachio with chocolate or salted caramel. Explore the latest ice cream flavor trends and satisfy your dessert cravings.


In conclusion, after carefully analyzing and taste-testing various store-bought pistachio ice creams, one can confidently declare that Haagen-Dazs’s pistachio ice cream reigns supreme.

Its creamy texture, rich pistachio flavor, and delightful crunch of real nuts make it a true indulgence for any ice cream aficionado.

Its unparalleled taste will transport you to a heavenly realm of frozen delights, leaving you craving for more with every spoonful.

Truly a pistachio lover’s dream come true!

Leave a Comment