The Best Store-Bought Pumpkin Pie Brands Worth Buying

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. See our disclosure policy.

They say, ‘You can’t judge a book by its cover,’ but when it comes to store-bought pumpkin pie, appearances can be deceiving.

The 8 Best Store-Bought Pumpkin Pie Brands 0

As you stand in the bakery aisle, surrounded by rows of golden crusts and tantalizing aromas, you find yourself faced with a delicious dilemma.

Which one should you choose? The answer lies in the taste, texture, and overall experience of the pie.

So, as you navigate the world of pre-made pumpkin pies, let us guide you through a mouthwatering journey that will leave you craving for more.

Key Takeaways

  • Jessie Lord Premium Pumpkin Pie and Jessie Lord Pre-baked Pumpkin Pie are worth the purchase, with a rich and creamy filling and a tender and flaky pie crust.
  • The Village PieMaker Pumpkin Pie tastes like homemade with a thicker and creamier filling made with real butter.
  • Whole Foods Market Vegan Pumpkin Pie and Whole Foods Market Pumpkin Pie are suitable for vegetarians and vegans, made with plant-based ingredients. The Vegan Pumpkin Pie also offers convenient reheating instructions.
  • Marie Callender’s Frozen Pumpkin Pie Dessert is best for those who want a convenient and delicious pumpkin pie without the hassle of making it from scratch. It has traditional flavors and a flaky crust.

Which is The 8 Best Store-Bought Pumpkin Pie Brands You Can Buy?

When it comes to store-bought pumpkin pie, there are a few options that stand out.

First, there’s the Premium Pumpkin Pie, known for its rich and creamy filling and flaky crust.

Then, there’s The Village PieMaker Pumpkin Pie, which boasts a perfect balance of spices and a homemade taste.

If you’re looking for a vegan option, the Vegan Pumpkin Pie is a great choice, with its velvety texture and delightful pumpkin flavor.

For a classic and convenient option, you can’t go wrong with the Oven Fresh Pumpkin Pie or the Frozen Pumpkin Pie Dessert.

8. Jessie Lord Premium Pumpkin Pie

The 8 Best Store-Bought Pumpkin Pie Brands 8

For those looking for a delicious and convenient store-bought dessert option, the Jessie Lord Premium Pumpkin Pie is the perfect choice. This 34 oz pie is just the right size for a gathering, offering 8 generous servings per pie.

The limited availability of this product, especially during the Thanksgiving season, adds to its appeal and makes it a highly sought-after treat.

Customers have mostly given positive reviews, praising the pumpkin flavor and the perfect blend of spices. However, there have been a few comments about an unpleasant soap-like taste and a soft, mushy crust.

Despite these few criticisms, overall customer satisfaction remains high, with many praising the pie’s taste and quality.

If you’re in need of a delicious pumpkin pie without the hassle of baking from scratch, the Jessie Lord Premium Pumpkin Pie is definitely worth a try.

Best For: Those who want a convenient and delicious dessert option without the hassle of baking from scratch.

Pros:

  • Generous serving size with 8 servings per pie.
  • Limited availability during holidays, making it a special treat.
  • Positive customer reviews praising the pumpkin flavor and blend of spices.

Cons:

  • Some feedback regarding an unpleasant soap-like taste.

7. The Village PieMaker Pumpkin Pie

The 8 Best Store-Bought Pumpkin Pie Brands 7

The Village PieMaker Pumpkin Pie is the ultimate choice for those who crave a store-bought pumpkin pie that rivals homemade with its sweet crust, creamy filling, and perfectly balanced spices.

This 40 OZ store-bought pie is made without hydrogenated fats or high fructose corn syrup, bleached or bromated flour, and synthetic nitrates or nitrites. Instead, it’s made with real butter, giving it a rich and buttery taste.

Numerous positive reviews attest to the pie’s homemade flavor and quality ingredients. Customers have praised its sweet crust, great filling, and perfect amount of spice. They’ve also mentioned that it’s thicker and creamier compared to other pies.

The Village PieMaker Pumpkin Pie is a convenient option as it comes frozen and only requires baking for about an hour and a half. Once baked, it needs an additional hour to cool.

Many customers have expressed their willingness to repurchase this pie, stating that it outshines homemade versions and ranks among the best pies they’ve ever tasted.

With its buttery and flaky crust, balanced spices, and creamy texture, The Village PieMaker Pumpkin Pie is a true delight for pumpkin pie lovers.

Best For: Pumpkin pie lovers who want a convenient and high-quality store-bought option that tastes like homemade.

Pros:

  • Made with real butter and quality ingredients
  • Sweet crust and creamy filling
  • Perfectly balanced spices

Cons:

  • Requires baking and cooling time

6. Whole Foods Market Vegan Pumpkin Pie

The 8 Best Store-Bought Pumpkin Pie Brands 6

Indulge in the Whole Foods Market Vegan Pumpkin Pie, a flavorful store-bought choice that satisfies both vegans and pumpkin pie enthusiasts.

This 28-ounce pie is made without hydrogenated fats or high-fructose corn syrup, ensuring a healthier option for those with dietary restrictions. It also avoids the use of bleached or bromated flours, prioritizing natural ingredients.

However, customer reviews reveal some aspects of this pie. Many complain about the lack of flavor and off consistency, describing it as bland, watery, and slightly clumpy. The crust is also a point of contention, with some customers claiming it’s cheaply made.

Dissatisfaction with Whole Foods’ deli and bakery items, as well as their quality control and customer service, is also expressed.

While some appreciate the vegan options and enjoy the pie filling, others suggest improvements to the pumpkin recipe and express their decision to not purchase this pie again until changes are made.

Best For: Vegans and individuals with dietary restrictions who are looking for a healthier pumpkin pie option.

Pros:

  • Made without hydrogenated fats or high-fructose corn syrup
  • Avoids the use of bleached or bromated flours
  • Offers vegan options for those with dietary restrictions

Cons:

  • Lack of flavor and off consistency

5. Sara Lee Oven Fresh Pumpkin Pie

The 8 Best Store-Bought Pumpkin Pie Brands 5

Sara Lee Oven Fresh Pumpkin Pie is a delicious store-bought choice for pumpkin lovers seeking a convenient and tasty dessert. This frozen pie weighs 34 oz and comes in a ready-to-bake foil pan for easy preparation.

The filling is made with real pumpkin and a signature blend of cinnamon and spices, delivering the traditional flavors of the holiday season. Each bite offers a delightful crunch from the flaky, golden crust.

With over 60 years of experience, Sara Lee ensures premium ingredients and a unique baking process for a fresh taste and quality. While some customers found the pie to be too sweet, many rave about its deliciousness and make it a regular treat.

However, there have been a few reviews mentioning a strong, waxy smell while baking and issues with the middle of the pie remaining runny.

Despite these concerns, Sara Lee Oven Fresh Pumpkin Pie remains a popular choice among pumpkin enthusiasts.

Best For: Pumpkin lovers looking for a convenient and delicious option for satisfying their cravings.

Pros:

  • Made with real pumpkin and a blend of cinnamon and spices for a rich and smooth filling.
  • Baked in a flaky, golden crust that adds a delicious crunch.
  • Ready-to-bake foil pan for easy preparation.

Cons:

  • One review mentioned a crust that wasn’t flaky and a runny filling.

4. Marie Callender’s Frozen Pumpkin Pie Dessert

The 8 Best Store-Bought Pumpkin Pie Brands 4

For those who want a convenient and delicious dessert option, Marie Callender’s Frozen Pumpkin Pie Dessert is the perfect store-bought choice.

This 36-ounce pie is great for finishing off your Thanksgiving or Christmas dinner, or enjoying holiday flavors at any time of year.

The pie features a flaky, homemade crust that adds a satisfying texture to every bite. The filling is a delightful combination of cinnamon, sugar, and a hint of nutmeg, creating a creamy and perfectly spiced experience.

Customers have raved about the pie’s delicious taste, with some considering it the best pumpkin pie they’ve ever had.

The pie can be easily prepared by baking it in the oven and serving it warm. For an extra special treat, try serving it with whipped cream or ice cream.

With its affordable price and homemade taste, Marie Callender’s Frozen Pumpkin Pie Dessert is a must-have for any pumpkin pie lover.

Best For: Pumpkin pie lovers looking for a convenient and delicious dessert option.

Pros:

  • Made with a flaky, homemade crust for a satisfying texture.
  • Delightful combination of cinnamon, sugar, and nutmeg for a creamy and perfectly spiced filling.
  • Affordable price and homemade taste.

Cons:

  • Some customers find the pie to be overly sweet.

3. JJ’s Bakery Pumpkin Spice Pie

The 8 Best Store-Bought Pumpkin Pie Brands 3

JJ’s Bakery Pumpkin Spice Pie is a top choice for pumpkin pie enthusiasts who want a truly decadent and mouthwatering store-bought option.

This pie stands out from the rest with its amazing flavor and real pumpkin filling. Unlike other store-bought pies that can be bland and chewy, JJ’s Bakery delivers a pie that’s perfectly spiced and has a smooth texture.

The pie is also nicely packaged and protected, ensuring that it arrives in great condition.

The JJ’s Bakery Pumpkin Spice Pie is a great option for those looking for a high-quality, delicious pumpkin pie that can be easily enjoyed at home.

Best For: Pumpkin pie enthusiasts who want a high-quality, delicious store-bought option.

Pros:

  • Excellent flavor and real pumpkin filling
  • Smooth texture
  • Nicely packaged and protected

Cons:

  • Packaging and protection issues in some cases

2. Jessie Lord Pre-baked Pumpkin Pie

The 8 Best Store-Bought Pumpkin Pie Brands 2

Jessie Lord Pre-baked Pumpkin Pie is a 9′ premium pie filled with delicious pumpkin filling in a flaky pie crust. The crust is good, although it falls short of the perfection of homemade.

However, the flavor and amount of spices in this store-bought pie are just right, not overwhelming. The pie has a smooth and light consistency without a heavy pumpkin taste, unlike most store-bought options.

The texture of the pie is nice and soft, with the crust having the perfect amount of crumbliness and thickness.

The lack of proper packaging raises concerns about tampering and freshness, but the taste of this pie is undeniably delicious. If you’re looking for a convenient and tasty store-bought pumpkin pie, Jessie Lord Pre-baked Pumpkin Pie is a solid choice.

Best For: Those who want a convenient and tasty store-bought pumpkin pie without a heavy pumpkin taste.

Pros:

  • Delicious pumpkin filling with the right blend of spices.
  • Smooth and light consistency with a nice and soft texture.
  • Perfect amount of crumbliness and thickness in the crust.

Cons:

  • Packaging concerns, including the lack of a safety seal and a box.

1. Whole Foods Market Pumpkin Pie

The 8 Best Store-Bought Pumpkin Pie Brands 1

Whole Foods Market Pumpkin Pie is a standout option for best store-bought pumpkin pie.

It offers an authentic pumpkin flavor, a perfect balance of sweetness and spice, and a commitment to using high-quality ingredients. Weighing 28 ounces, this pie delivers both in taste and value.

Customers love the flavorful and delicious pie, considering it to be the best combination available.

They appreciate that Whole Foods Market pies look good, taste like they’re bakery quality, and are relatively inexpensive.

The pie’s appeal is further enhanced by the fact that it contains no hydrogenated fats or high-fructose corn syrup, and no bleached or bromated flours.

However, a few customers have had mixed experiences, with some finding the pie dry and lacking in flavor.

Overall, Whole Foods Market Pumpkin Pie is a solid choice for those seeking a store-bought pie that tastes homemade.

Best For: Those seeking a store-bought pumpkin pie with authentic flavor and high-quality ingredients.

Pros:

  • True pumpkin flavor with the right balance of sweetness and spice
  • No hydrogenated fats or high-fructose corn syrup
  • No bleached or bromated flours allowed

Cons:

  • Some customers found the pie to be dry and lacking in flavor

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make any adjustments to the store-bought pumpkin pie to enhance its flavor?

To improve the taste of store-bought pumpkin pie, consider adding spices such as cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves. You can also get creative by adding toppings like whipped cream, caramel sauce, or crushed graham crackers. For an extra special treat, serve the pie warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.

How long does a store-bought pumpkin pie typically last in the refrigerator?

Store-bought pumpkin pie typically lasts in the refrigerator for about 3-4 days. To extend its shelf life, cover it tightly with plastic wrap or foil. When serving, add a dollop of whipped cream or a sprinkle of cinnamon for extra flavor. To reheat, pop it in the oven at 350°F for 10-15 minutes.

Are There Any Store-Bought Pumpkin Pies That Are Gluten-Free or Suitable for Individuals With Dietary Restrictions?

There are plenty of gluten-free, dairy-free, sugar-free, vegan, and nut-free alternatives available when it comes to store-bought pumpkin pies. There are options for individuals with various dietary restrictions.

Can I freeze a store-bought pumpkin pie for later consumption?

Yes, you can freeze a store-bought pumpkin pie for later. Adjust the taste with whipped cream or cinnamon. Follow freezing guidelines and thaw in the fridge overnight. Reheat in the oven for a warm treat. Proper storing is key for freshness. Enjoy!

Are there any store-bought pumpkin pies that are made with organic or natural ingredients?

When comparing organic vs conventional store-bought pumpkin pies, it’s important to consider the benefits of natural ingredients. Homemade pies often trump store-bought options in terms of health implications and comparing ingredient labels.

Conclusion

Indulging in the perfect store-bought pumpkin pie is like discovering a treasure chest hidden within the aisles.

Its velvety smoothness embraces your taste buds, transporting you to autumnal bliss with each delectable bite.

The rich aroma of cinnamon and nutmeg lingers in the air, awakening nostalgic memories of cozy gatherings.

As you savor the last crumb, a warm feeling of contentment washes over you, reminding you that sometimes, the best things in life can be found right in the convenience of a store.

New Store-Bought Posts You Might Like

So, you're on the quest for the holy grail of store-bought breadsticks, are you? Well, fear not, for I am ...
So, you've decided to venture into the world of store-bought teriyaki sauce. The options are vast and varied, each promising ...
You may not be aware that there is a wide array of store-bought cherry pies available for your indulgence. From ...
Find out the truth behind the theory that there is a best store-bought cornbread mix out there waiting for you, ...
Munch on the most delectable microwave popcorn that will leave your taste buds tingling with delight, as we reveal the ...
Not all store-bought dry rubs are created equal, but we have discovered a hidden gem that will leave you craving ...
In this discussion, we will explore the top contenders for the best store-bought chicken broth, leaving you eager to discover ...
Looking for the best store-bought flatbread pizza? Check out our top picks for delicious and convenient flatbread pizzas that you ...
Looking for the best store-bought lasagna? Check out our top picks for the tastiest and most convenient store-bought lasagna options ...
Looking for the best store-bought hot dog chili? Check out our top picks for the tastiest and most flavorful chili ...

Latest Posts You Might Like

Leave a Comment