The Best Store-Bought Cherry Pie by Favorite Brands at Grocery Store

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. See our disclosure policy.

You may not be aware that there is a wide array of store-bought cherry pies available for your indulgence.

From the classic flaky crust to unique variations like cherry pie cheesecake, there are options to suit every palate.

But which one at grocery store is truly the best? Well, that’s what we’re here to uncover.

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cherry Pie Brands 0

So, buckle up and get ready to embark on a mouthwatering journey through the world of store-bought cherry pies, as we explore the taste, texture, and overall experience of some of the top contenders.

Get ready to discover the ultimate cherry pie that will leave you craving for more.

Key Takeaways

  • Katz Gluten Free Personal Size Cherry Pie offers a healthier alternative to traditional sweets with its gluten-free and dairy-free options.
  • Cyrus O’Leary’s Baked Cherry Pie is a local and affordable choice with a delicious and flaky crust, although some reviewers mention finding cherry pits and an unpleasant taste in the filling.
  • Mrs. Smith’s Original Flaky Crust Cherry Pie provides a classic homemade taste with its dense and crunchy crust and delicious tart cherry filling, although it may not be as full of cherries and juice as expected.
  • The Village PieMaker Cherry Pie Cheesecake offers a unique and gourmet option made with high-quality ingredients, combining the flavors of cherry pie and cheesecake. However, specific directions are not provided.
  • Entenmann’s Minis Cherry Snack Pies are a convenient snack option with a delicious cherry filling and individually wrapped for on-the-go snacking. However, they have a high calorie content and may not be suitable for those watching their calorie intake.

Which is The 10 Best Cherry Pies Grocery Store Brands You Can Buy?

So, you’re on the hunt for the best store-bought cherry pie? Look no further!

Let me introduce you to some mouthwatering grocery store options:

  • Katz Gluten Free Personal Size Cherry Pie
  • Cyrus O’Leary’s Baked Cherry Pie
  • Mrs. Smith’s Original Flaky Crust Cherry Pie
  • The Village PieMaker Cherry Pie Cheesecake
  • Entenmann’s Minis Cherry Snack Pies.

Each of these pies offers a unique flavor profile and delicious crust, making them top contenders for the title of the best store-bought cherry pie.

1. JJ’s Bakery Lightly Glazed Snack Pies

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cherry Pie Brands 1

The top choice for a best store-bought cherry pie is undoubtedly JJ’s Bakery Lightly Glazed Snack Pies, with their excellent flavor, real fruit filling, and packaging that protects the pies from squashing. These delectable pies are a true delight for your taste buds.

The rich and tangy flavor of the cherries bursts in your mouth with each bite. The filling is made from real fruit, giving it a natural and authentic taste.

The pies are lightly glazed, adding a hint of sweetness without overpowering the cherry goodness.

The packaging is sturdy and reliable, ensuring that your pie arrives in perfect condition. No more worrying about crushed pies! With JJ’s Bakery Lightly Glazed Snack Pies, you can indulge in a delicious cherry pie anytime, anywhere.

Best For: Those who are looking for a delicious cherry pie with a real fruit filling and sturdy packaging.

What’s So Great

  • Excellent flavor and real fruit filling
  • Sturdy packaging protects pies from squashing
  • Light glaze adds a hint of sweetness without overpowering the cherry taste

Good to Know

  • Boxes were greasy and falling apart

2. Whole Foods Market Cherry Pie

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cherry Pie Brands 2

For those seeking the store-bought cherry pie, look no further than Whole Foods Market’s Cherry Pie. Weighing in at a generous 19 ounces, this pie is made without any hydrogenated fats or high-fructose corn syrup.

Plus, it’s made with only the best flours – no bleached or bromated ones allowed. When it comes to taste and quality, this cherry pie doesn’t disappoint.

The sweet and tart flavor is perfectly balanced, with plenty of juicy fruit filling. The crust, however, received mixed reviews. Some found it to be excellent, while others described it as doughy and raw tasting.

It’s worth noting that the quality of this pie has changed recently, as it’s now advertised as an Amazon Brand and lacks the mention of Whole Foods’ artisanal bakery items. Overall, this cherry pie is a delicious option, perfect for indulging in all by yourself or sharing with loved ones.

Best For: Individuals who prefer a sweet and tart cherry pie without hydrogenated fats or high-fructose corn syrup.

What’s So Great

  • Generous 19-ounce size
  • No hydrogenated fats or high-fructose corn syrup
  • Made with high-quality flours

Good to Know

  • Mixed reviews on the crust, with some finding it doughy and raw tasting

3. Fresh Brand Cherry Pie

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cherry Pie Brands 3

With its juicy cherries and perfectly sweetened filling, Fresh Brand Cherry Pie is the delectable grocery store choice for those craving a mouthwatering dessert that surpasses all expectations.

This 26-ounce frozen pie boasts a flaky crust that encases a generous amount of filling. While some may find the pie slightly under-baked to their preferences, it can easily be enhanced with toppings or refreshed in the oven for a better taste.

Despite a review claiming bland tasteless cherries and a terrible doughy crust, the majority of consumers rave about the surprisingly good flavor and texture of this pie.

The cherries are sweet, but not overly so, and the crust is thick enough to hold the ample filling.

The fact that it arrives as a normal pie, rather than frozen as described, is a pleasant surprise. With its perfect size and wide appeal, Fresh Brand Cherry Pie is loved by everyone.

4. Hostess Cherry Fruit Pie

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cherry Pie Brands 4

When it comes to finding the store-bought cherry pie, look no further than the Hostess Cherry Fruit Pie. This 4.5 ounce pie is a delicious treat filled with cherry fruit goodness. It’s the perfect on-the-go snack for those who crave a sweet and fruity indulgence.

Made by Hostess, a well-known baker of America’s favorite snack cakes, you can trust the quality and taste of this pie. While it may be a bit on the expensive side, the convenience it offers is absolutely worth it.

The pie is large in size and packed full of filling, satisfying your cherry pie cravings in every bite. Some reviewers mentioned a slightly bitter aftertaste, but overall, it’s a tasty option for cherry pie lovers.

So grab a Hostess Cherry Fruit Pie and enjoy its delectable taste, perfect shape, generous size, and pleasant aroma.

Best For: Cherry pie lovers who enjoy a convenient and on-the-go snack.

What’s So Great

  • Delicious cherry fruit filling
  • Large size pie snack with generous filling
  • Pleasant bouquet and shape

Good to Know

  • Slightly bitter aftertaste

5. Marie Callender’s Cherry Crunch Pie Frozen Dessert

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cherry Pie Brands 5

The store-bought cherry pie option, Marie Callender’s Cherry Crunch Pie Frozen Dessert, features an extra-flaky, golden crust made from scratch and is topped with a delectable streusel topping for those seeking a truly indulgent and crunchy experience.

This 36-ounce pie is made with premium ingredients, including tart red cherries, ensuring a burst of sweet and tangy flavors in every bite.

The crust is perfectly baked, providing a satisfyingly crisp texture that complements the luscious cherry filling.

The streusel topping adds a delightful crunch that elevates the overall taste and texture of the pie. With zero trans fat and no artificial flavors or preservatives, Marie Callender’s Cherry Crunch Pie Frozen Dessert not only satisfies your cravings but also offers a guilt-free dessert option.

So, go ahead and indulge in this delicious pie, perfect for ending a meal or celebrating any occasion.

Best For: Those who crave a truly indulgent and crunchy cherry pie experience.

What’s So Great

  • Extra-flaky, golden crust made from scratch
  • Delectable streusel topping adds a delightful crunch
  • Burst of sweet and tangy flavors from premium tart red cherries

Good to Know

  • Some customers found the pie to have less cherries and more crumbs than expected

6. Entenmann’s Minis Cherry Snack Pies

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cherry Pie Brands 6

For those seeking a delectable and convenient treat, look no further than Entenmann’s Minis Cherry Snack Pies – the epitome of indulgence in a perfectly portioned, sweet and tangy delight.

These individually wrapped pies are a mini version of the American classic, featuring a lightly glazed pie crust filled with a luscious cherry filling.

Despite their small size, these grocery store pies pack a big punch of flavor. Each bite is a burst of sweetness and tanginess that will leave you craving more. They’re perfect for snacking on-the-go or enjoying as a mid-morning or afternoon treat.

However, be warned, these pies aren’t for the calorie-conscious, as they contain around 480 calories each. But if you’re willing to indulge, these Mini Cherry Snack Pies from Entenmann’s are a delicious choice.

Best For: Individuals looking for a sweet and tangy indulgence in a perfectly portioned snack.

What’s So Great

  • Delicious and luscious cherry filling
  • Conveniently individually wrapped for on-the-go snacking
  • Mini size allows for guilt-free indulgence

Good to Know

  • High calorie content (approximately 480 calories per pie)

7. The Village PieMaker Cherry Pie Cheesecake

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cherry Pie Brands 7

With its delectable combination of cherry pie and cheesecake, The Village PieMaker Cherry Pie Cheesecake is a mouthwatering treat that will satisfy even the most discerning dessert enthusiasts.

This 32 oz frozen dessert is made with high-quality ingredients, ensuring a delicious and indulgent experience.

What sets this grocery store cherry pie cheesecake apart from others is its commitment to using only the finest ingredients.

The Village PieMaker refuses to include hydrogenated fats, high fructose corn syrup, bleached or bromated flour, or synthetic nitrates or nitrites in their products. This dedication to quality shines through in every bite.

According to a satisfied customer, this dessert exceeded all expectations, even making a great breakfast snack. With no stop words found and no specific directions provided, The Village PieMaker Cherry Pie Cheesecake is a convenient and delectable treat that’s sure to impress.

Best For: Dessert enthusiasts who appreciate high-quality ingredients and a delicious combination of cherry pie and cheesecake.

What’s So Great

  • Made with high-quality ingredients
  • No hydrogenated fats, high fructose corn syrup, bleached or bromated flour, or synthetic nitrates or nitrites
  • Convenient frozen dessert

Good to Know

  • No specific directions provided

8. Mrs. Smith’s Original Flaky Crust Cherry Pie

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cherry Pie Brands 8

When it comes to the store-bought cherry pie, Mrs. Smith’s Original Flaky Crust Cherry Pie is a delectable choice that will satisfy even the most discerning pie lovers. This 35 oz frozen pie is a family favorite and for good reason.

The crust is simply amazing – dense, crunchy, and deliciously crisp. It provides the perfect foundation for the tart cherry filling, which is bursting with flavor.

The cherries are full and amazing, offering a delightful balance of tartness and sweetness.

And here’s the best part – this pie tastes just like the best of homemade pie. It’s one of the few store-bought products that doesn’t resemble frozen food at all.

So go ahead and indulge in Mrs. Smith’s Original Flaky Crust Cherry Pie – you won’t be disappointed!

Best For: Pie lovers who want a delicious and convenient frozen cherry pie option.

What’s So Great

  • Amazing crust that’s dense, crunchy, and deliciously crisp.
  • Delicious tart cherry filling with full and amazing cherries.
  • Tastes just like the best of homemade pie.

Good to Know

  • Smaller size and not as full of cherries and juice as expected.

9. Cyrus O’Leary’s Baked Cherry Pie

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cherry Pie Brands 9

If you’re in the mood for a mouthwatering cherry pie that boasts locally produced goodness, a delicious flaky crust, and a generous filling of cherries, then Cyrus O’Leary’s Baked Cherry Pie is the perfect choice for you.

This pie is a true delight for cherry pie enthusiasts. The locally produced ingredients ensure that you’re getting the freshest and highest quality cherries in every bite.

The crust is flaky and delicious, providing the perfect complement to the sweet and tart filling. Not to mention, the affordable price makes this pie even more enticing.

However, it’s important to note that some reviewers have found cherry pits in their pies, which can be a bit of a disappointment. Additionally, a few people have mentioned an unpleasant taste in the filling.

Despite these minor drawbacks, Cyrus O’Leary’s Baked Cherry Pie is still a top contender in the store-bought cherry pie category.

Best For: Cherry pie enthusiasts who value locally produced ingredients and a flaky crust.

What’s So Great

  • Locally produced with fresh and high-quality cherries
  • Delicious and flaky crust
  • Affordable price

Good to Know

  • Possibility of finding cherry pits in the pie

10. Katz Gluten Free Personal Size Cherry Pie

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cherry Pie Brands 10

For those seeking a delicious gluten-free cherry pie option, look no further than Katz Gluten Free Personal Size Cherry Pie. This grocery store pie is perfect for individuals with dietary restrictions as it’s dairy-free, nut-free, soy-free, and gluten-free.

The pie comes in a convenient 11.5-ounce packaging and is praised for its great taste and wonderful crust. Customers also appreciate the excellent customer service provided by Katz Gluten Free.

However, there are some drawbacks to consider. Some customers have noted that the filling is thin and there’s more sauce than cherries.

Additionally, there have been instances of broken crust upon delivery. Despite these minor flaws, the taste and quality of the Katz Gluten Free Personal Size Cherry Pie are still highly regarded.

It’s a healthier alternative to traditional sweets and can be enjoyed by the whole family, even those who don’t require a gluten-free diet.

Best For: Individuals with dietary restrictions who are seeking a delicious gluten-free cherry pie option.

What’s So Great

  • Dairy-free, nut-free, soy-free, and gluten-free, making it suitable for those with dietary restrictions.
  • Praised for its great taste, wonderful crust, and balanced sweetness.
  • Offers regular specials and free shipping promotions for added value.

Good to Know

  • Some customers have noted a thin filling and more sauce than cherries.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does a store-bought cherry pie typically last before it goes bad?

Typically, a store-bought cherry pie lasts around 3-5 days before it starts to go bad. Of course, this depends on a few factors like the brand and how it’s stored.

Make sure to check the expiration date before indulging in a slice. To extend its shelf life, keep it in the fridge and cover it tightly with foil or plastic wrap.

Signs of spoilage include mold, a funky smell, or a slimy texture. Remember, proper handling and storage are key to enjoying a delicious, fresh cherry pie.

Can store-bought cherry pies be frozen for later consumption?

Store-bought cherry pies can absolutely be frozen for later consumption! Freezing tips? Wrap it tightly in plastic wrap and seal it in a freezer bag.

Best brands? Look out for renowned pastry companies like Marie Callender’s or Sara Lee.

Reheating instructions? Pop it in the oven at 350°F for about 20 minutes or until it’s warm and gooey.

Alternative uses? Crumble it over ice cream or use it as a base for a delicious trifle.

Homemade vs store-bought? Well, nothing beats a homemade pie, but sometimes convenience wins!

Are there any recommended serving suggestions or accompaniments for store-bought cherry pie?

When it comes to serving store-bought cherry pie, there are plenty of ways to make it even more delightful. To start, consider adding some recommended toppings like a dollop of whipped cream or a sprinkle of powdered sugar.

For an extra indulgence, pair it with a scoop of the best ice cream flavors like vanilla or chocolate. Remember, serving temperature is key, so warm it up slightly or enjoy it chilled.

Get creative with plating ideas and don’t forget to complement it with a refreshing beverage of your choice.

What are some common allergens found in store-bought cherry pies?

When it comes to store-bought cherry pies, it’s important to be mindful of allergens. Allergen labeling is crucial, as it helps you identify potential risks. Cross contamination is a concern, so it’s best to look for brands that take extra precautions to prevent it.

Common allergenic ingredients include wheat, soy, and nuts, so if you have allergies, make sure to check the label. Thankfully, there are allergy-friendly alternatives and brands available that cater to various dietary needs.

Are store-bought cherry pies usually made with fresh cherries or a canned cherry filling?

When it comes to store-bought cherry pies, you might find that they’re usually made with a canned cherry filling rather than fresh cherries. This is because using fresh cherries can be more expensive and time-consuming for mass production.

However, don’t let that discourage you! Store-bought cherry pies can still have a good quality and taste. While homemade pies may have a slight edge in flavor, the convenience and consistency of store-bought options make them a popular choice.

Cherry Pie Bestsellers

1. JJ's Bakery Lightly Glazed Snack Pies

JJ's Bakery Lightly Glazed Snack Pies 4oz (Pack of 6) (Cherry)
JJ's Bakery Lightly Glazed Snack Pies 4oz (Pack of 6) (Cherry)

    2. Whole Foods Market Cherry Pie

    Whole Foods Market, Cherry Pie Half
    Whole Foods Market, Cherry Pie Half

      3. Fresh Brand Cherry Pie

      Amazon Fresh Brand, Cherry Pie, 26 Oz (Frozen)
      Amazon Fresh Brand, Cherry Pie, 26 Oz (Frozen)

        Leave a Comment