The Best Store-Bought Bagels to Jump Start Your Day

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. See our disclosure policy.

It’s a fact that people love bagels.

We usually head to the local bagel shop to find the best bagels. There’s a big difference between bagels from the grocery stores and freshly baked bagels.

The best store-bought bagels we tasted for this article are as close to fresh bagels you can buy from mom-and-pop shop in a neighbourhood.

The Best Store-Bought Bagels to Jump Start Your Day 0

There’s just something about a plain bagel, even though they are available in many delicious flavors. Plain bagels are a great choice for a filling and satisfying meal.

They can be eaten whole, like a doughnut or used to bookend a bacon, eggs and cheese sandwich or split and topped with cream cheese and capers.

Pre-packaged bagels are now available in many grocery stores. You can still buy best bagels at your local bagel shop, but equally best bagels are also readily available from most grocery stores nowadays.

Which is The 10 Best Store-Bought Bagel Brands Near Me?

Biting into a chewy, fresh bagel with your coffee in the morning is a great joy.

There’s nothing like the comfort of a dense bagel with thick cream cheese. This is indeed the perfect way for you to start your morning.

It may not be possible to visit your local bagel shop every time. As such, having some delicious store-bought bagels in stock is a great idea and life saver sometime.

The local grocery store has a wide variety of bagels to satisfy the most discerning bagel lover.

You can choose from plain, sesame or cinnamon raisin, whole wheat, poppy seeds, or everything bagels.

You can find bagels that satisfy your taste buds as good as what you can buy from the authentic local bagel shops.

Now, what are the best store-bought bagels that you can buy in stores? We have searched far and wide for the most delicious, chewy bagels.

This is the best list of the most popular store-bought bagel brands that you can bite with trust and confidence.

10. Einstein Bros Take & Toast Asiago Bagels

einstein bros take toast asiago bagels store-bought via 452

Toasting is an easy way to give a bag of store-bought bagels a new lease on life.

If you are looking for a tasty, cheesy bagel, then the Asiago bagels from Einstein Bros Take & Toast is the perfect choice.

These bagels are filled with Asiago cheese. They are really delicious! These bagels were so good that you will crave for them for breakfast, lunch and dinner.

The Einstein Bros Take & Toast Asiago bagels are flavorful and soft. This bagel is full of flavor and Asiago cheese.

These bagels are perfect for cheese lovers. Einstein’s plain bagels were the crispiest, chewiest and most satisfying when split open and topped with butter.

They are worth it, as you do not need to add anything to enjoy them.

Key Features:

  • Einstein Bros. Bagels, Take & Toast, Asiago, 18.5 oz (5 ct)
  • Three Cheese blend of Asiago, Romano, and Parmesan
  • No artificial flavors, colors, preservatives, or high fructose corn syrup


  • Fresh, high-quality ingredients
  • Convenience of enjoying bakery-fresh bagels from home
  • Soft and delicious, perfect for breakfast sandwiches


  • May need to be heated up before consumption
  • Not suitable for immediate use upon delivery
  • Bagels arrive frozen and need to be sliced before toasting or baking

9. Sara Lee’s Cinnamon Raisin Bagel

sara lees cinnamon raisin bagel store-bought via 452

Sara Lee’s Cinnamon Raisin Bagel is a great breakfast choice!

Sara Lee is a company that’s known for its desserts like pound cakes and pies. As such it makes sense then, that they would go after cinnamon raisin bagel lovers.

This bagel contains whole wheat flour rich in fiber and nutrients. This bagel is a favorite because of its cinnamon and raisins that enrich further the taste of it.

Key Features:

  • 6 pre-sliced bagels
  • 20 oz package
  • 0g Trans Fat


  • Sweet cinnamon flavor
  • Soft and chewy texture
  • Convenient and easy to prepare


  • Lack of strong cinnamon taste
  • Some customers found a lack of whole raisins
  • Pricey compared to other brands

8. Utopia Bagels of New York

utopia bagels of new york store-bought via 452

Utopia Bagels is not a brand that you can find only in grocery stores, but being shipped nationwide so that you can enjoy the best bagels right at home.

If you visit their bagel shop in NYC, they use only the best ingredients and bake them fresh all day. The staff is friendly and always willing to help you select the perfect bagel.

You don’t have to worry if you aren’t in New York. Utopia Bagels delivers nationwide, so you can enjoy their delicious bagels wherever you are in the USA.

Their prices are reasonable, and they accept any size order. You can order frozen products and stock up your pantry.

7. Pepperidge Farm Cinnamon Raisin Bagels

pepperidge farm cinnamon raisin bagels store-bought via 452

Who doesn’t like a cinnamon-raisin bagel?

For some reason, the grocery store bagel industry has become obsessed with cinnamon-raisin.

Pepperidge Farm is known for making some of the best bagel flavors. For some unknown reasons, it seems like this cinnamon-raisin flavor is not doing well with most New Yorkers.

Pepperidge Farm’s Cinnamon Raisin bagels made with raisins are sweetened just right and these are great for breakfast or as a quick snack at any time.

If you want a tasty way to start the day or something to keep you going until lunchtime, you should pick up some Pepperidge Farm Cinnamon Raisin bagels.

This perfectly chalky and dusty store-bought bagels are boiled and baked to authentic perfection. You will not be disappointed!

6. Canyon Bakehouse Everything Bagel

canyon bakehouse everything bagel store-bought via 452

The Everything Bagel is available in all bagel shops in New York City. Why?

Well, New York City is the place where Everything Bagel was created. This store-bought bagel with perfect flavor, has a little bit of everything as the name suggests.

You could smell garlic when you buy Canyon Bakehouse and instantly you knew you are in for a treat. And for sure, you will not be disappointed.

Everything Bagels of Canyon Bakehouse are gluten free and the bagels are cut through all the way, making it easy to halve and toast them.

The inner part of this breading is soft, chewy and delicious. The outside of the bagel is golden and becomes crunchy when toasted.

The bagel looks more authentic with the different seasonings they put on it.

Canyon Bakehouse’s Gluten Free Everything bagels are made with water, brown rice, tapioca flour, potato starch and cultured brown rice flour.

They also contain organic agave, dehydrated onions, garlic, whole grain Sorghum flour, xanthan, egg whites and baking powder, sunflower seeds, poppy seeds, sesame seeds and sea salt.

These bagels contain 100% whole grains and are gluten-free.

You may be a bagel lover like us and have felt that gluten-free bagels have been missing in your life.

Grab this best store-bought bagels today and enjoy these delicious breakfast treats!

Key Features:

  • Brand: Canyon Bakehouse
  • Type: Everything Bagel
  • Size: 14 oz
  • Certified gluten-free & non-GMO
  • Kosher, presliced bagels
  • Free from gluten, wheat, dairy, soy, and nuts


  • Delicious taste and texture
  • Excellent option for those who need to follow a gluten-free diet
  • Comparable to traditional bagels
  • Conveniently sliced for easy consumption
  • Suitable for individuals with various dietary restrictions


  • Relatively expensive for the amount provided
  • Some confusion about the size of the bagels

5. 365 Bagels Plain by Whole Foods Market

365 bagels plain by whole foods market store-bought via 452

You can rest assured that these plain bagels are gluten-free and non-GMO and they are certified so.

We were surprised how well these came out perfect from the toaster. Obviously not gourmet bagels, but the consistency was more like bagels than crumbly bread as with other bagel brands.These 365 bagels were also pre-sliced and split apart easily.

says Consumericious on a review at

The bagels have a delicious flavor thanks to the unbleached wheat, brown sugar, cultured wheat and malted barley flour. They are also flavored with sea salt, wheat gluten, yeast, and wheat flour.

You can order them quickly and easily from Whole Foods via Amazon.

Key Features:

  • Brand: 365 by Whole Foods Market
  • Product: Bagels Plain 6 Count
  • Size: 18 Ounce


  • Made with premium ingredients
  • Reasonably priced
  • Good taste and texture


  • Reports of bagels being stale or turning moldy

4. Lender’s New York Style

lenders new york style store-bought via 452

Lender’s New York Style has the perfect place for your bagel fix.

You can find a variety of toppings and flavors by Lender’s, so there’s always something new you can try.

The perfect combination of malt, yeast and sugar gives these authentic New York style bagels a crisp outer crust and fluffy interior.

To give them a traditional taste, they are also boiled in water before baking. Lender’s will satisfy any craving, whether you prefer plain bagels or cream cheese.

You can also buy Lender’s New York Style Bagels at Amazon store and most grocery stores in the USA.

Key Features:

  • Size: Smaller than bakery bagels, but slightly bigger than mini bagels
  • Taste: Similar to Thomas’ bagels, good flavor when toasted
  • Texture: Crunchy on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside


  • Good flavor, especially when toasted
  • Convenient and versatile for quick meals
  • Can be purchased online for freshness


  • Smaller size compared to other bagels
  • Not as crusty when toasted

3. Thomas’ Plain Mini Bagels

thomas plain mini bagels store-bought via 452

Thomas’ offers mini bagels with big bagel flavor.

Thomas’ mini bagels are special thanks to one hundred twenty-five years of baking expertise result in the freshly-baked goodness and deliciousness of Thomas’ regular-size bagels.

This bite-sized bagel’s crust is soft and has a lovely sheen.

You can enjoy this bagels by make mini breakfast sandwiches using bacon, an egg and cheese.

Add cream cheese and lox, and lightly toast the bagels for a New York style favorite. Spread butter and jam on the bagels for a sweeter version.

Thomas’ Plain Mini Bagels are pre-sliced to make toasting and topping easy! Pre-sliced bagels are great for on-the-go snacks at any time.

You can also dip them into a sauce for snacking anytime, anywhere.

Your kids might enjoy creating their own pizza bites using their favorite toppings, such as pepperoni, sausages, fresh vegetables, and shredded cheese.

Mini bagels are also great for creating sandwiches. They fit into lunchboxes perfectly, and kids love them.

You can be confident that the bagels you choose are made from high-quality ingredients and do not contain high fructose syrup.

Thomas’ Mini-Bagels is that and among the best store-bought bagels you must never miss out from your shopping list.

Key Features:

  • Thomas Plain Mini Bagels
  • 10 Pre-Sliced Mini Bagels
  • No High Fructose Corn Syrup
  • 15 oz bag


  • Convenient for busy mornings
  • Can be enjoyed right out of the bag
  • Can be topped with cream cheese or used to make savory breakfast sandwiches
  • Can be kept in the freezer for many weeks
  • Suitable for those who don’t usually eat a whole bagel


  • Some customers may prefer larger bagels
  • No specific directions provided for preparation or storage

2. Dave’s Killer Bread Epic Everything

daves killer bread epic everything store-bought via 452

Try Dave’s Killer Bread Epic Everything bagels if you want an everything-bagel that’s packed with flavor.

These organic store-bought bagels from Dave’s Killer Bread are perfect for those who love whole grain bagels.

These bagels, which contain five super grains including barley, millet, quinoa, and wheat, are free from the additives and gums that can be normally found in pre-packaged wholegrain bagels.

The crispy texture and flavor of this bagels are amazing. The spices were balanced and not overpowering.

They are perfect for any type of topping including cream cheese, bacon, avocado and other favorites.

Overall, these store-bought bagels are definitely worth a try for those who want something different from the usual everything bagel.

Key Features:

  • Daves Killer Bread Organic Everything Bagels
  • 16.75 oz bag
  • Pre-sliced bagels
  • Certified USDA Organic and Non GMO Project Verified
  • 26 grams of whole grains per serving
  • Made with highest quality organic ingredients


  • Nice and fresh taste
  • Palatable and enjoyable
  • Lighter and doesn’t sink in your stomach
  • Easy chew compared to other bagels
  • Slight wheat-y aftertaste
  • Good seasoning, not overpowering
  • Best toasted
  • Freezes well and defrosts nicely


  • More delicate texture, doesn’t form wet dough in your mouth
  • Pricey

1. Thomas’ Plain Pre-Sliced Bagels

thomas plain pre sliced bagels store-bought via 452

Thomas’ Plain Bagels make the breakfast perfect and these store-bought bagels are satisfying and filling but not heavy.

Enjoy this classic bagels that is perfect on its own with butter or cream cheese.

They have a delicious flavor and are perfect at any time. These store-bought bagels contain whole wheat flour and are packed with nutrients.

They’re also low in fat and calories, so they are a great choice for those who want to eat healthy and tasty.

Thomas’ plain bagels will please you whether they are eaten plain or with your favorite spread.

The next time you need a quick and tasty breakfast, try this best store-bought bagels by Thomas’. Thomas’ Plain Bagels are indeed a great way to start your day.

Key Features:

  • Contains 6 Thomas Plain Bagels
  • Pre-sliced for convenience
  • Crunchy on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside when toasted
  • 0g trans fat per serving
  • No high-fructose corn syrup
  • Cholesterol-free


  • Delicious taste
  • Versatile and can be enjoyed with various toppings or fillings
  • Freezes well and stays fresh for weeks


  • Inconsistent cutting of the bagels

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Store-Bought Bagels Healthier Than Homemade Ones?

Store-bought bagels may seem convenient, but are they healthier than homemade ones? Let’s analyze the pros and cons. While they may lack some nutritional value and taste compared to homemade, they can be cheaper and more convenient.

Can Store-Bought Bagels Be Frozen and Reheated?

Yes, store-bought bagels can be frozen and reheated. The best methods involve wrapping them tightly in plastic wrap or placing them in a freezer bag. However, the taste and texture may not be as good as when they are fresh.

What Is the Shelf Life of Store-Bought Bagels?

Store-bought bagels have varying shelf lives depending on the brand and packaging. To maintain freshness, check the expiration date and follow recommended storage instructions. Properly stored bagels can last for several days, but be cautious of mold growth.

Are There Any Gluten-Free Options Available in the Store-Bought Bagel Market?

Looking for gluten-free options in store-bought bagels? Some brands offer alternatives, but the taste and texture may not compare to homemade. Tips: check specialty sections, read labels, and experiment with different brands for the best fit.

Are Store-Bought Bagels Suitable for Individuals With Food Allergies?

Store-bought bagels may not be suitable for individuals with food allergies due to ingredient transparency issues, cross contamination risks, and labeling accuracy concerns. While some allergen-free options exist, store-bought options have limitations.


In conclusion, after indulging in the mouthwatering selection of store-bought bagels, it’s clear that some rise above the rest. With their soft, chewy texture and delectable flavors, these bagels are a breakfast game-changer.

Whether you prefer the classic simplicity of plain or the boldness of everything bagels, there’s a store-bought option that will satisfy your cravings.

So, next time you’re in need of a quick and satisfying morning treat, don’t hesitate to grab one of these top-notch bagels from your local store.

Latest Posts You Might Like

Leave a Comment