When it comes to store-bought pimento cheese, it’s like searching for a needle in a haystack – you want that perfect blend of creamy, tangy, and a hint of spice.
But fear not, because in the sea of grocery store options, there are a few shining stars that might just steal the show.
Let’s unravel the mysteries of these beloved spreads and uncover which Pimento cheese will reign supreme on your cracker or sandwich.
Which is The 10 Best Pimento Cheese Grocery Store Brands You Can Buy?
When it comes to store-bought pimento cheese, Palmetto Cheese Original Pimento Cheese Spread offers a classic, creamy option that pairs well with crackers or sandwiches.
Melanie’s Medleys Dip Pimento Cheese provides a tangy and flavorful twist, perfect for those looking for a unique taste.
For a more artisanal grocery store choice, Homegrown Craft Pimento Cheese stands out with its handcrafted blend of cheeses and peppers.
1. Kraft Pimento Cheese Spread
When seeking a flavorful and versatile grocery store cheese spread ideal for snacking or dipping, consider the Kraft Pimento Cheese Spread as a top choice.
This 5 oz pack of 2 is perfect for spreading on crackers or using as a dip for carrots and celery, enhanced with chopped up olives for an extra kick.
While many customers love the taste and versatility of this spread, some have raised concerns about its price and availability in certain regions. Mixed reviews mention both the delight at the cheese spread and disappointment with its cost.
There have been complaints about changes in flavor and price over the years, as well as confusion surrounding discontinuation rumors. Despite these challenges, customers continue to seek clarification on availability and call for Kraft to address pricing and quality concerns.
Best For: Those who enjoy a flavorful and versatile cheese spread for snacking or dipping.
What’s So Great
- Loved by customers for its taste and versatility
- Great snack product for spreading on crackers or as a dip for carrots and celery
- Enhanced with chopped up olives for an extra kick
Good to Know
- Some customers find the product expensive
2. Mythreesons Emmy’s Original Pimento Cheese
For those seeking a creamy and flavorful grocery store pimento cheese option, Mythreesons Emmy’s Original Pimento Cheese stands out as the ultimate choice.
This 10 oz delight offers a perfect balance of creaminess and sharpness, enhanced by just the right amount of pimentos.
It serves as a versatile addition to your kitchen, whether as a topping on hamburgers, a scrumptious sandwich filling, or a classic pairing with crackers. Customers rave about its authentic taste, reminiscent of homemade versions, making the price tag worth every penny.
The thick consistency and cheesy flavor have left customers satisfied and eager to repurchase. With its delightful taste and nostalgic charm, Mythreesons Emmy’s Original Pimento Cheese is a must-try for any pimento cheese enthusiast.
Best For: Those looking for a versatile and delicious pimento cheese option that offers a perfect balance of creaminess and sharpness.
What’s So Great
- Authentic taste reminiscent of homemade versions
- Versatile usage as a topping, filling, or with crackers
- Thick consistency and cheesy flavor
Good to Know
- May be pricier compared to other pimento cheese options
3. Mythreesons Spicy White Cheddar Pimento Cheese
Embracing a bold blend of thick, real cheddar shreds and a balanced touch of spice, Mythreesons Spicy White Cheddar Pimento Cheese stands out as a top choice for those seeking an authentic, artisanal pimento cheese experience.
The specialty spread offers large, authentic cheddar cheese pieces that add a satisfying texture to each bite. The subtle kick of spice complements the creaminess of the grocery store cheese without overpowering the flavors, making it a well-balanced option for spice enthusiasts.
Customers rave about the genuine taste and appreciate the absence of artificial ingredients, highlighting the care taken in preparing this pimento cheese.
While some find it a bit pricey, the majority agrees that the quality and taste justify the cost, making Mythreesons a highly recommended choice for a premium pimento cheese selection.
Best For: Those who appreciate a premium, artisanal pimento cheese experience with a balanced touch of spice and real cheddar texture.
What’s So Great
- Authentic, thick cheddar shreds provide a satisfying texture.
- Balanced touch of spice enhances the flavor without overpowering.
- Carefully prepared with real ingredients, free from artificial additives.
Good to Know
- Some may find the price point to be on the higher end.
4. Sweet Grass Dairy Pimento Cheese
Featuring a unique blend of Thomasville tomme, Dukes mayo, Piquillo peppers, and Pimentoon from Spain, Sweet Grass Dairy Pimento Cheese offers a zesty, creamy texture with a hint of sweetness that caters to discerning cheese enthusiasts.
This take on the classic Southern staple provides a spreadable option that stands out for its quality ingredients.
However, some customers have voiced concerns about its saltiness and high mayo content, which may overshadow the cheese flavor for some palates. While praised for its high-quality cheeses, there have been occasional complaints about mold or off-tastes.
If you appreciate a unique twist on pimento cheese with a touch of sweetness and are willing to overlook potential flavor discrepancies, Sweet Grass Dairy Pimento Cheese could be worth a try.
Best For: Cheese enthusiasts looking for a unique twist on traditional pimento cheese with a zesty and creamy texture.
What’s So Great
- Made with high-quality ingredients including Thomasville tomme and Piquillo peppers.
- Offers a spreadable option with a hint of sweetness from pimento.
- Suitable for soy-free diets.
Good to Know
- Some customers find it too salty.
5. Zilks Foods Smoked Gouda Pimento Cheese
With its creamy texture, rich flavors, and perfect balance of pimento goodness, Zilks Foods Smoked Gouda Pimento Cheese is a top choice for those seeking a gourmet upgrade to the traditional Southern favorite.
This 8-ounce jar of perfection offers a harmonious blend of pimento peppers and Gouda cheese, showcasing culinary mastery in every bite.
Customers rave about the shredded grocery store cheese consistency that sets Zilks Foods apart from other brands, ensuring a delightful texture with each spread.
Whether enjoyed on flatbread crackers, mixed into egg salad, or used as a sandwich spread, the versatility of Zilks Foods Smoked Gouda Pimento Cheese makes it a go-to option for various culinary adventures.
Elevate your snacking experience with this flavorful and indulgent treat that has become a staple in many homes.
Best For: Those who seek a gourmet twist on traditional Southern flavors with a creamy and rich pimento cheese experience.
What’s So Great
- Creamy texture and rich flavors elevate snacking and culinary creations.
- Shredded cheese consistency offers a delightful texture for spreading and mixing.
- Versatile usage in various dishes like flatbread crackers, sandwiches, and appetizers.
Good to Know
- Limited quantity in an 8-ounce jar may not be sufficient for frequent consumption.
6. Zilks Foods Pimento Cheese
For those seeking a pimento cheese with a velvety smooth texture and a harmonious blend of flavors, Zilks Foods Pimento Cheese stands out as a top choice.
The creamy texture and rich flavors create a perfect balance of pimento goodness, showcasing a culinary mastery evident in each jar.
With a transformative experience that transports you to a world of pimento cheese euphoria, Zilks Foods Pimento Cheese is truly a standout product.
Customer reviews rave about its deliciousness, with some claiming it as the best they’ve ever tasted and even rating it beyond perfection.
While there have been some negative comments about cheese chunks being too big and hard, the overall consensus highlights Zilks Foods Pimento Cheese as a must-try for any pimento cheese enthusiast.
Best For: Cheese connoisseurs looking for a transformative pimento cheese experience.
What’s So Great
- Velvety smooth texture
- Harmonious blend of flavors
- Culinary mastery evident in each jar
Good to Know
- Cheese chunks may be too big and hard for some
7. Zilks Foods Jalapeno Pimento Cheese
Boasting a fiery kick and creamy richness, Zilks Foods Jalapeno Pimento Cheese stands out as a top grocery store choice for those seeking a zesty twist on a classic favorite.
The specialty cheese combines the bold flavor of jalapenos with the classic pimento cheese base, creating a spicy and cheesy deliciousness that’s perfect for spreading on crackers, sliced carrots, or veggies.
While some customers find it slightly pricey, the overall positive reception highlights its tasty and fantastic qualities, making it a must-buy for gatherings and events.
Despite mixed opinions on the level of spiciness, Zilks Foods Jalapeno Pimento Cheese remains a favorite for those who enjoy a kick in their cheese spread.
Consider adding more jalapenos for an extra fiery experience.
Best For: Cheese lovers who enjoy a spicy kick in their spreads.
What’s So Great
- Bold and fiery jalapeno flavor
- Creamy richness and great taste
- Perfect for gatherings and events
Good to Know
- Some customers may find it slightly pricey
8. Homegrown Craft Pimento Cheese
Indulge in the creamy and flavorful HOMEGROWN Craft Pimento Cheese, a Southern classic with a delightful kick of spice.
This 11 oz product from Georgia, made with cow’s milk, offers a fresh cheese flavor complemented by shredded pieces of cheese and an infusion of pimentos.
While it serves as a tasty dip for veggies and crackers or a delicious sandwich spread, some customers have encountered mold issues.
The spicy classic spread warms easily in the microwave, making it ideal for grilled cheese. Despite positive feedback on taste and quality, concerns exist regarding its spiciness, texture, sweetness, and saltiness.
To enhance the overall experience, improvements in quality control, adjustments in spiciness levels, and addressing texture issues are recommended.
Best For: Those who enjoy a flavorful and spicy twist on a classic Southern pimento cheese dip.
What’s So Great
- Fresh cheese flavor with a kick of spice
- Creamy and colorful spread
- Ideal for grilled cheese sandwiches
Good to Know
- Some customers may find it too spicy
9. Melanie’s Medleys Dip Pimento Cheese
Ideal for those seeking a family-friendly and mildly spiced option, Melanie’s Medleys Dip Pimento Cheese stands out in the realm of store-bought pimento cheeses.
This 7.5-ounce container offers a convenient dip that can be enjoyed with crackers, veggies, or as a sandwich spread.
While some customers appreciate its mild flavor that isn’t too spicy, others find it somewhat bland and greasy, suggesting that it might benefit from additional seasoning.
However, negative reviews mention that it lacks the traditional sweetness and spreadability expected from southern-style pimento cheese.
Notably, this product contains red bell peppers instead of the more traditional pimentos, which could be a deciding factor for those who prefer a more classic taste. Remember to keep it refrigerated for the best taste and texture.
Best For: Those looking for a family-friendly, mildly spiced store-bought pimento cheese option that can be used as a dip or sandwich spread.
What’s So Great
- Family-friendly and not too spicy.
- Convenient dip for snacking with crackers or veggies.
- Led to the discovery of other tasty products for some customers.
Good to Know
- Somewhat bland and greasy, may require additional seasoning.
10. Palmetto Cheese Original Pimento Cheese Spread
For those seeking a delectable and versatile option for their culinary adventures, Palmetto Cheese Original Pimento Cheese Spread stands out as the ultimate choice among store-bought pimento cheeses.
Made with real Wisconsin Sharp Cheddar Cheese, this southern-style spread offers a perfect blend of mayonnaise, cream cheese, pimentos, and spices.
Its gluten-free, low carb, and keto-friendly nature, packaged in a resealable 11-ounce container, makes it a convenient choice for various recipes.
While customers praise its flavor and authenticity, some critique the spice level and flavor accuracy.
However, the overall positive feedback on texture, taste, and effectiveness makes Palmetto Cheese Original Pimento Cheese Spread a top contender in the realm of store-bought pimento cheeses.
Best For: Those looking for a convenient and flavorful store-bought pimento cheese option with a homemade taste.
What’s So Great
- Made with real Wisconsin Sharp Cheddar Cheese for authentic flavor.
- Versatile for use as a spread, dip, or topping in various recipes.
- Gluten-free, low carb, and keto-friendly for dietary preferences.
Good to Know
- Some customers may find the spice level and flavor accuracy lacking.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are there any vegan or dairy-free options for store-bought pimento cheese?
When looking for dairy-free options for store-bought pimento cheese, you can explore plant-based alternatives and vegan spreads. These options often use alternative ingredients like cashews, nutritional yeast, or tofu to create creamy and flavorful non-dairy cheeses.
Be sure to check the label for dairy-free certifications and ingredients to ensure you’re getting a pimento cheese that fits your dietary preferences. Experimenting with different brands can help you find the perfect vegan option for your taste buds.
Can store-bought pimento cheese be frozen for later use?
When it comes to freezing store-bought pimento cheese, there are some tips to keep in mind. To maintain flavor, consider adding extra seasoning before freezing.
Texture preferences may change slightly after thawing, but a good stir can help.
Serve the thawed pimento cheese as a spread on crackers or sandwiches.
Store the frozen pimento cheese in an airtight container for best results.
Experiment with flavor variations like adding jalapeños or bacon for some extra kick!
Are there any low sodium or reduced fat options available for store-bought pimento cheese?
Looking to indulge without the guilt? Dive into the world of low-sodium and reduced-fat store-bought pimento cheese. With flavorful substitutes and healthier alternatives, you can find customizable choices that won’t compromise on taste.
Explore gluten-free varieties and low-calorie options to satisfy your cravings while keeping an eye on your health. From zesty to mild, there’s a pimento cheese out there for every palate.
Your taste buds and waistline will thank you!
Are there any store-bought pimento cheese brands that use organic or locally sourced ingredients?
When searching for store-bought pimento cheese made with sustainable sourcing, locally made, and organic ingredients, keep an eye out for brands that focus on small batch production and artisanal options. These companies often prioritize quality ingredients and support local farmers, making their products a more environmentally friendly choice.
Can store-bought pimento cheese be used in recipes other than just as a spread?
Want to elevate your dishes with a twist? Store-bought pimento cheese isn’t just for spreading! Get creative with it in the kitchen.
Try incorporating it into casseroles, stuffed peppers, or grilled sandwiches for a burst of flavor. Experiment with different cooking techniques like baking or broiling to enhance its creaminess.
Pair it with ingredients like bacon, jalapenos, or caramelized onions for unique flavor combinations. The possibilities are endless!
