The Best Store-Bought Cocktail Sauce by Favorite Brands at Grocery Store

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. See our disclosure policy.

If you’re a fan of seafood and love a good kick of flavor, Heinz Cocktail Sauce might be your go-to choice.

But have you ever wondered if there’s a store-bought cocktail sauce out there that could elevate your shrimp cocktail game even further?

Maybe one that surprises your taste buds with a unique blend of ingredients or an unexpected level of spiciness?

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cocktail Sauce Brands 0

Stay tuned as we explore a variety of cocktail sauce options at grocery store that could potentially change the way you enjoy your seafood favorites.

Key Takeaways

  • Heinz, 365, Amazon Fresh, Bookbinders, and SCHLOTTERBECK & FOSS offer top-notch store-bought cocktail sauces.
  • Various options cater to specific preferences like spiciness, health-conscious choices, and unique flavors.
  • Consider factors like taste, versatility, affordability, and ingredients when selecting the best cocktail sauce.
  • Users should be mindful of potential cons like extreme spiciness, packaging issues, and varying flavor perceptions.

Which is The 10 Best Cocktail Sauce Grocery Store Brands You Can Buy?

When it comes to the best store-bought cocktail sauce, Heinz is a classic favorite with its tangy and flavorful profile.

If you’re looking for an organic grocery store option, 365 by Whole Foods Market offers a fresh and natural taste.

For a more gourmet experience, Bookbinders or SCHLOTTERBECK & FOSS are excellent choices with rich and complex flavors.

1. Heinz Cocktail Sauce

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cocktail Sauce Brands 1

For those seeking a zesty and versatile condiment to elevate their seafood dishes, Heinz Cocktail Sauce stands out as the top choice among store-bought options.

This 12 oz. bottle of Heinz Original Cocktail Sauce offers a great taste loved by the entire family. Ideal for shrimp, fish, and shellfish, this gluten-free grocery store sauce contains 0 mg of cholesterol.

With ingredients like tomato concentrate, horseradish, onion powder, and garlic powder, it adds just the right kick to your favorite dishes.

Each serving contains 70 calories and 0 g of trans fat. The twist-off cap guarantees secure storage, making it convenient for various recipes. Customers rave about its flavor, versatility, and ability to enhance classic recipes, making it a must-have for seafood lovers.

Best For: Those who enjoy a flavorful and versatile condiment to enhance their seafood dishes.

What’s So Great

  • Loved by the entire family for its great taste
  • Versatile for use in various recipes
  • Adds value to meals and enhances classic recipes

Good to Know

  • Mixed feedback on packaging and delivery experience

2. 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Cocktail Sauce

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cocktail Sauce Brands 2

Look for the Whole Foods Market’s 365 Organic Cocktail Sauce if you prefer a fat-free option with a unique blend of flavors that sets it apart from other store-bought cocktail sauces.

This cocktail sauce, coming in a convenient 10 fl oz size, meets rigorous quality standards and is free from prohibited ingredients.

While some users compare its taste to Cross and Blackwell, others appreciate its experimentation with thickening agents like guar gum. It pairs well with chilled shrimp, making it a versatile condiment beyond just seafood.

However, feedback on its sweetness varies, with some finding it slightly sweet and enjoyable, while others feel it may be too sweet for their liking.

Overall, the 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Cocktail Sauce offers a good alternative for those seeking a unique, fat-free option.

Best For: Those looking for a fat-free and versatile cocktail sauce option with a unique flavor profile.

What’s So Great

  • Versatile condiment beyond just seafood
  • Experimentation with thickening agents like guar gum
  • Meets rigorous quality standards

Good to Know

  • Mixed reviews on sweetness level

3. Amazon Fresh Cocktail Sauce

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cocktail Sauce Brands 3

Indulge in the Amazon Fresh Cocktail Sauce, a flavorful and affordable option perfect for seafood lovers seeking a high-quality sauce without artificial guarantees.

This 12 oz bottle offers a great balance between taste and value, making it a popular choice among customers looking for a budget-friendly option.

While some reviews mention concerns about sweetness and ingredients, the majority of users are satisfied with the overall quality and price point.

The Amazon Fresh label guarantees that you’re getting high-quality food at a reasonable cost, making it a go-to choice for many consumers.

Whether you’re enjoying it with shrimp or mixing it with spaghetti for an extra kick, Amazon Fresh Cocktail Sauce is a reliable option that delivers on both taste and affordability.

Best For: Seafood enthusiasts looking for a budget-friendly and flavorful cocktail sauce option.

What’s So Great

  • Affordable pricing
  • Good taste and flavor
  • Versatile usage with seafood and pasta dishes

Good to Know

  • Mixed reviews on sweetness

4. Bookbinders Cocktail Sauce

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cocktail Sauce Brands 4

With its bold flavor and perfect balance of horseradish, Bookbinders Cocktail Sauce stands out as the top choice at grocery store for those seeking a zesty accompaniment to seafood dishes.

This sauce offers a great flavor with just the right kick – not too sweet, but with plenty of spicy goodness. The ideal amount of horseradish adds a unique depth to the overall taste, making it a favorite among users.

Whether you’re enjoying shrimp at home or dining out, Bookbinders Cocktail Sauce elevates the seafood experience to a whole new level.

Users highly recommend this sauce for its exceptional flavor profile and spicy kick that surpasses other store-bought options. Plus, the convenience of finding it on Amazon makes it a go-to choice for seafood lovers everywhere.

Best For: Seafood enthusiasts looking for a flavorful and zesty cocktail sauce with a perfect balance of horseradish.

What’s So Great

  • Bold flavor with the right amount of kick
  • Ideal balance of horseradish for depth of taste
  • Great accompaniment for seafood dishes, especially shrimp

Good to Know

  • Small 10 oz bottles can be more expensive

5. SCHLOTTERBECK & FOSS Cocktail Sauce

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cocktail Sauce Brands 5

For those seeking a store-bought cocktail sauce that boasts a harmonious blend of natural ingredients and exquisite flavor, SCHLOTTERBECK & FOSS Cocktail Sauce stands out as a top grocery store choice.

This 8 fl oz sauce is crafted with a combination of horseradish, concentrated tomatoes, cane sugar, vinegar, sea salt, garlic, and onion, making it a gluten and lactose-free option.

Consumers have long praised its delicious taste and quality, with many likening it to restaurant-grade cocktail sauce.

While some find it slightly sweet, suggesting a sugar-free version, overall, the sauce receives high recommendations for its flavor profile, affordability, and overall quality.

Some enthusiasts even enjoy enhancing its taste by adding extra horseradish for a bolder kick. Give this sauce a try if you’re looking for a premium store-bought option that delivers on both taste and natural ingredients.

Best For: Those who appreciate a high-quality, gluten and lactose-free cocktail sauce with a slightly sweet flavor profile.

What’s So Great

  • Delicious taste likened to restaurant-quality sauce
  • Crafted with natural ingredients
  • Affordable option for premium cocktail sauce

Good to Know

  • Slightly sweet for some consumers

6. OLD BAY Cocktail Sauce

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cocktail Sauce Brands 6

If you appreciate bold, zesty flavors that enhance your seafood experience, the OLD BAY Cocktail Sauce stands out as the best choice among store-bought options.

This classic dipping sauce boasts a blend of 18 spices and herbs, including celery salt and paprika, delivering a perfect balance of flavors.

Its thick texture and just-right spiciness make it ideal for improving shrimp cocktail, oysters, or crab cake sandwiches.

With real horseradish and a touch of tomato, this sauce embodies the unique taste of OLD BAY Seasoning, a brand with over 75 years of seasoning expertise.

Customers rave about its zesty kick, praising its ability to enhance seafood dishes. Whether you’re a Maryland native or a seafood enthusiast, this sauce is sure to add a Chesapeake Bay flair to your dining experience.

Best For: Seafood lovers looking for a zesty and flavorful dip to elevate their seafood dishes.

What’s So Great

  • Bold blend of 18 spices and herbs for a perfect balance of flavors.
  • Versatile sauce that complements shrimp cocktail, oysters, and crab cake sandwiches.
  • Real horseradish and touch of tomato enhance the unique taste of OLD BAY Seasoning.

Good to Know

  • Some may find the spiciness too strong, but it can be adjusted by mixing with ketchup.

7. St. Elmo Extra Spicy Cocktail Sauce

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cocktail Sauce Brands 7

Indulge in the fiery and invigorating experience of St. Elmo Extra Spicy Cocktail Sauce, a must-have condiment for those who crave bold flavors with their seafood.

Crafted with 119 years of expertise, this world-famous sauce packs a punch with its unique spice and long-lasting flavor profile.

The fresh-ground horseradish root, balanced with tomato paste and hints of lemon, creates a perfect harmony of heat and tanginess. Its light citrus notes make it an ideal companion for shrimp and other seafood delicacies.

St. Elmo Extra Spicy Cocktail Sauce has garnered praise from customers who appreciate its restaurant-quality taste without the need for extra horseradish.

Be warned, its spiciness may require a cool beverage on standby, but the flavor explosion is well worth it.

Best For: Seafood lovers who enjoy bold and spicy flavors with their shrimp and other seafood dishes.

What’s So Great

  • Packed with fresh-ground horseradish for a fiery kick.
  • Light citrus notes add a refreshing touch to the flavor profile.
  • Long-lasting taste without the need for extra horseradish.

Good to Know

  • May be extremely spicy for some, requiring a cool beverage to balance out the heat.

8. Legal Sea Foods Spicy Cocktail Sauce

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cocktail Sauce Brands 8

When seeking a store-bought cocktail sauce that packs a punch with a serious dose of spice and tang to elevate your seafood experience, consider Legal Sea Foods Spicy Cocktail Sauce.

This 8.75-ounce bottle is a flavor powerhouse, balancing out briny, ocean-fresh flavors with extra horseradish, jalapeños, and chili powder. The zippy kick it delivers pairs perfectly with chilled shrimp or raw oysters, adding an extra layer of excitement to every bite.

Part of the Stonewall Kitchen Family of Brands, Legal Sea Foods by Stonewall Kitchen brings the taste of the sea right to your table.

If you’re a fan of bold flavors and enjoy a bit of heat, this spicy cocktail sauce is a must-try for your next seafood feast.

Best For: Seafood enthusiasts looking for a bold and spicy kick to enhance their dining experience.

What’s So Great

  • Intense spicy and tangy flavors
  • Balanced combination of extra horseradish, jalapeños, and chili powder
  • Perfect complement to chilled shrimp or raw oysters

Good to Know

  • Packaging may be prone to damage

9. Stonewall Kitchen New England Cocktail Sauce

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cocktail Sauce Brands 9

For seafood enthusiasts seeking a zesty and authentic New England cocktail sauce with a kick, Stonewall Kitchen New England Cocktail Sauce stands out as the top choice among store-bought options.

This 8.25-ounce jar packs a punch with its traditional New England recipe featuring horseradish, lemon, and a blend of seasonings that elevate the flavor profile to a whole new level.

Made with premium ingredients and free from unwanted chemicals, this sauce is a hit among those who prefer a tangy and slightly hot cocktail sauce for their shrimp.

While some may find it a tad spicier than expected, its perfect blend of flavors makes it a must-have in your pantry for all your seafood dipping needs.

Best For: Seafood lovers looking for a tangy and slightly hot cocktail sauce to elevate their shrimp dipping experience.

What’s So Great

  • Made with premium ingredients and free from unwanted chemicals
  • Zesty and traditional New England recipe with horseradish, lemon, and seasonings
  • Perfect blend for cocktail sauce, loved by many for its quality

Good to Know

  • Some may find it a bit too hot

10. Primal Kitchen Unsweetened Organic Cocktail Sauce

The 10 Best Store-Bought Cocktail Sauce Brands 10

Crafted with USDA organic ingredients and a zesty kick from organic horseradish, Primal Kitchen’s Unsweetened Organic Cocktail Sauce stands out as a top choice for those seeking a sugar-free option to complement their seafood dishes.

This sauce is a favorite among those following Paleo, Keto, or Whole30 diets due to its clean ingredient list and absence of added sugars.

Its bold flavor pairs perfectly with seafood favorites like calamari and crab cakes, enhancing the overall dining experience.

While some customers rave about its taste and appreciate the sugar-free aspect, others have expressed concerns about the price point and consistency.

Despite mixed opinions on flavor and quality, many enjoy this cocktail sauce with classic dishes like shrimp cocktail, making it a versatile option for seafood lovers.

Best For: Those following Paleo, Keto, or Whole30 diets looking for a sugar-free cocktail sauce to enhance their seafood dishes.

What’s So Great

  • Made with USDA organic ingredients
  • Certified Paleo, Keto Certified, Whole30 Approved
  • Suitable for seafood dishes like calamari and crab cakes

Good to Know

  • Mixed opinions on flavor and quality

Frequently Asked Questions

Are there any store-bought cocktail sauces that are specifically gluten-free or vegan?

Looking for gluten-free or vegan cocktail sauces? Some brands offer options that cater to these dietary preferences. You can also whip up your own homemade recipes for a healthier twist.

Explore the health benefits of these variations and savor the diverse flavor profiles available. Whether you choose store-bought or make it from scratch, finding the perfect cocktail sauce can be as satisfying as uncovering a hidden gem in a treasure chest.

Can store-bought cocktail sauce be used for anything other than seafood dishes?

Sure, cocktail sauce can be a versatile addition to your dishes beyond just seafood. Get creative with recipes like cocktail sauce meatloaf, cocktail sauce glazed chicken wings, or cocktail sauce-marinated tofu.

Experiment with flavor pairings like using it in a BBQ sauce base or mixing it into a stir-fry for a tangy kick. Try out some cocktail sauce hacks like using it as a dipping sauce for fries or as a condiment on burgers.

Taste test comparisons might surprise you!

How long does store-bought cocktail sauce typically last once opened?

Once opened, store-bought cocktail sauce typically lasts for about 2-3 weeks in the refrigerator. Make sure to check the expiration date on the bottle and follow proper storage guidelines to maintain its freshness.

To extend its usability timeframe, consider sealing the bottle tightly after each use and storing it in the coldest part of your fridge. These preservation methods will help prevent spoilage and guarantee the sauce stays flavorful for as long as possible.

Are there any low-sodium options available for those looking to reduce their salt intake?

Looking to reduce salt intake? Low-sodium alternatives for cocktail sauce can be a game-changer.

These options offer healthier choices without compromising on flavor. Homemade recipes often allow you to control sodium content, providing health benefits and a more tailored taste.

When comparing store-bought versions, consider taste differences and how they may impact your enjoyment of seafood dishes. Experimenting with various flavor profiles may lead you to discover a new favorite.

Are there any store-bought cocktail sauces that are made with all-natural ingredients and no preservatives?

When searching for store-bought cocktail sauces made with all-natural ingredients and no preservatives, consider exploring homemade alternatives for a fresh and customizable option. By sourcing quality ingredients, you can control the flavor profiles and guarantee health benefits.

Although homemade versions might lack the shelf stability of commercial products, the taste and health advantages are worth the effort. Experimenting with different recipes can lead to a sauce that perfectly suits your preferences.

Cocktail Sauce Bestsellers

1. Heinz Cocktail Sauce

Heinz Cocktail Sauce (12 oz Bottle)
Heinz Cocktail Sauce (12 oz Bottle)

    2. 365 by Whole Foods Market Organic Cocktail Sauce

    365 by Whole Foods Market, Organic Cocktail Sauce, 10 Fl Oz
    365 by Whole Foods Market, Organic Cocktail Sauce, 10 Fl Oz

      3. Amazon Fresh Cocktail Sauce

      Amazon Fresh, Cocktail Sauce, 12 Oz
      Amazon Fresh, Cocktail Sauce, 12 Oz

        Leave a Comment