Did you know that Americans consume over 1.3 billion chicken wings during the Super Bowl alone?
With such a staggering number, it’s no wonder that buffalo sauce has become a staple condiment in many households.
But with so many options available, how do you know which store-bought buffalo sauce is truly the best?
Well, fear not, because in this discussion, we will explore some of the top contenders in the market, revealing their unique flavors, heat levels, and overall quality.
So, whether you’re a heat seeker or prefer a milder kick, keep reading to discover the perfect buffalo sauce that will elevate your next wing-eating experience to new heights.
Key Takeaways
- Wing Time Buffalo Wing Sauce is a versatile option that strikes the perfect balance between heat and flavor, making it highly recommended for wings, buffalo chicken wraps, and salads.
- Hot Ones Buffalo Sauce is made with all-natural ingredients and has a mild heat level, perfect for use on hot wings or as a condiment for various dishes.
- Sweet Baby Ray’s Buffalo Wing sauce adds the right amount of spice and rich garlic flavor to wings, and a little goes a long way, making it cost-effective.
- Moore Sauce Wing Buffalo offers a perfect balance of heat and flavor, is low in carbs, and can be mixed into Ranch dressing for a kicked-up salad dressing. However, it may not be readily available in store chains and must be purchased online.
Which is The 10 Best Buffalo Sauce Store-Bought Brands You Can Buy?
When it comes to finding the best store-bought buffalo sauce, there are several options to consider.
Wing Time Buffalo Wing Sauce offers a tangy, spicy flavor that perfectly complements chicken wings.
Hot Ones Buffalo Sauce provides a fiery kick that’s sure to satisfy spicy food lovers.
Sweet Baby Ray’s Buffalo Wing, Moore Sauce Wing Buffalo, and Buffalo Wild Wings Sauce are also popular choices, each offering their own unique blend of flavors.
Ultimately, the best sauce will depend on your personal preferences for heat and taste.
1. Frank’s RedHot Buffalo Wings Hot Sauce
The authentic taste and versatility of Frank’s RedHot Buffalo Wings Hot Sauce make it the best store-bought buffalo sauce choice for anyone seeking a flavorful and fiery addition to their favorite dishes.
This 23 fl oz bottle offers the same authentic restaurant taste that was used in the original Buffalo wings created in Buffalo, NY in 1964. It’s also kosher certified, making it suitable for a wide range of dietary preferences.
Whether you’re looking to enhance the flavor of wings, drumsticks, sliders, quesadillas, or dips, this hot sauce is the perfect choice.
It’s also great for tailgating, nachos, and satisfying all your flavor needs. Customers rave about the flavor and heat of the sauce, with some even claiming to put it on everything.
The long-lasting bottle ensures you’ll always have it on hand, and many customers prefer it for making their own buffalo wings at home.
Even international customers appreciate the authentic taste and quality of Frank’s RedHot Buffalo Wings Hot Sauce.
While no specific usage directions are provided, the versatility of this sauce allows you to get creative in the kitchen.
Overall, Frank’s RedHot Buffalo Wings Hot Sauce is a reliable and flavorful option for anyone seeking a delicious buffalo sauce.
Best For: Those who enjoy spicy and flavorful dishes, especially buffalo wings.
What’s So Great
- Authentic restaurant taste
- Versatile, can be used on a variety of dishes
- Kosher certified
Good to Know
- No specific usage directions provided
2. 365 Organic Buffalo Wing Sauce
For those who appreciate the organic goodness of Whole Foods Market, the 365 Organic Buffalo Wing Sauce is a top choice for store-bought buffalo sauce.
This sauce is made without hydrogenated fats or high fructose corn syrup, and it contains no bleached or bromated flour.
It also avoids synthetic nitrates or nitrites, and it’s free from over 150 banned colors, flavors, preservatives, and other ingredients often found in food.
Reviewers have praised the organic aspect of the sauce, with one customer saying, ‘Love that it’s ORGANIC.’ The taste of the sauce has also received positive feedback, with one reviewer describing it as ‘super tasty.’
Some customers have even shared their own recipes, combining the sauce with other ingredients for a perfect flavor combination.
Whether you prefer a hot and flavorful sauce or a milder spice level, the 365 Organic Buffalo Wing Sauce has been praised for its perfect balance of heat.
Best For: Those who value organic ingredients and want a flavorful buffalo wing sauce without hydrogenated fats, high fructose corn syrup, bleached or bromated flour, synthetic nitrates or nitrites, and other banned additives.
What’s So Great
- Made with organic ingredients
- No hydrogenated fats or high fructose corn syrup
- Free from synthetic nitrates or nitrites
Good to Know
- Some customers may find the taste disappointing compared to other brands
3. Primal Kitchen No Dairy Buffalo Sauce
Creamy and medium heat, Primal Kitchen No Dairy Buffalo Sauce is the perfect store-bought choice for those who crave a flavorful and spicy buffalo sauce without dairy.
Made with creamy cashew butter, this vegan buffalo sauce delivers a rich and satisfying taste.
The combination of avocado oil, cayenne sauce, and spices gives it a tasty kick that’s just right for wings, burgers, cauliflower bites, and more.
It’s not only delicious but also meets dietary needs, as it’s Whole30 Approved, Certified Paleo, and Keto Certified.
Plus, it’s gluten-free and made without xanthan gum. Whether you’re coating wings, spicing up dips, or adding some heat to your burger or burrito, Primal Kitchen No Dairy Buffalo Sauce is sure to impress with its uncompromisingly delicious flavor.
Best For: Those looking for a flavorful and spicy buffalo sauce without dairy.
What’s So Great
- Made with creamy cashew butter for a rich and satisfying taste.
- Medium heat, perfect for wings, burgers, cauliflower bites, and more.
- Whole30 Approved, Certified Paleo, and Keto Certified.
Good to Know
- Some customers find it too spicy for certain dishes.
4. Yo Mama’s Foods Keto Buffalo Dipping Marinade & Wing Sauce
When it comes to choosing the store-bought brand of buffalo sauce, Yo Mama’s Foods Keto Buffalo Dipping Marinade & Wing Sauce stands out for its low-carb, sugar-free, and allergen-friendly formula.
This pack of two sauces is crafted with real butter, fresh garlic, and freshly farmed cayenne pepper, making it a flavorful and versatile option.
Yo Mama’s Foods Keto Buffalo Sauce can be used as a condiment and pantry staple to enhance various meals and dishes such as sandwiches, burgers, French fries, sliders, Kettle Chips, and hot dogs.
Customers appreciate the taste and quality of this sauce, as well as its sugar-free and artificial sweetener-free nature.
It’s also suitable for those following a keto or low-carb diet, as it contains no added sugar or high fructose corn syrup.
Additionally, it’s free from soy, guar gum, locust bean gum, and added sugar, making it suitable for individuals with food allergies.
Yo Mama’s Foods offers a range of other condiments, and customers are encouraged to try their full line of products.
Best For: Individuals following a keto or low-carb diet who are looking for a flavorful and allergen-friendly buffalo sauce.
What’s So Great
- Low-Zero carb and no added sugar
- Crafted with real butter, fresh garlic, and freshly farmed cayenne pepper
- Versatile and enhances the flavor of various meals and dishes
Good to Know
- Some customers may find the flavor not matching expectations or too similar to marinara sauce
5. Anchor Bar Sauce Wing Original
The Anchor Bar Sauce Wing Original is the go-to store-bought buffalo sauce for those who crave a perfect balance of heat and flavor.
This 12 oz bottle contains Anchor Bar’s original wing sauce, which offers a medium level of spice.
Made with a spectacular blend of cayenne pepper, vinegar, salt, garlic, and other secret ingredients, this sauce is known for its delicious flavor. It clings to wings effortlessly, leaving them moist and packed with flavor.
Not only is it great on wings, but it also complements beef, pork, ribs, and chicken. While some reviewers found it to be a bit vinegary, others praised its great flavor and medium spice level.
Overall, the Anchor Bar Sauce Wing Original is a versatile and tasty option for buffalo sauce enthusiasts.
Best For: Buffalo sauce enthusiasts who prefer a medium spice level and a perfect balance of heat and flavor.
What’s So Great
- Delicious flavor with a blend of cayenne pepper, vinegar, salt, garlic, and secret ingredients
- Clings to wings effortlessly, leaving them moist
- Versatile, can be used on beef, pork, ribs, and chicken
Good to Know
- Some reviewers found it to be a bit vinegary
6. Buffalo Wild Wings Sauce
For those who crave spicy and flavorful buffalo sauce, Buffalo Wild Wings Sauce (Wild) is the delicious store-bought choice available.
Customers have given positive reviews, describing it as a solid sauce with a good taste and a high, yet tolerable, heat level.
Some even claim that it rivals homemade sauces in quality. Users recommend using this sauce to add an extra kick to wings at local sports bars or drizzling it over lemon pepper wings for a delicious combination.
While there have been a few instances of damaged deliveries, the sellers have shown exceptional customer service by going above and beyond to resolve the issue.
Personal preferences vary, but many consider Buffalo Wild Wings Sauce (Wild) their favorite among the BDUBS sauces.
In general, customers agree that it’s a good sauce that satisfies their spicy cravings.
Best For: Those who enjoy spicy and flavorful buffalo sauce.
What’s So Great
- Spicy and flavorful
- High heat level, yet tolerable
- Comparable to homemade sauces
Good to Know
- Some instances of damaged deliveries
7. Moore Sauce Wing Buffalo
With its perfect balance of heat and flavor, Moore Sauce Wing Buffalo is the go-to choice for anyone craving delicious, tangy buffalo sauce.
This 16 oz store-bought pack of 2 is perfect for wings and shrimp, offering a nice kick without being too spicy.
It has a pleasant taste and is low in carbs, making it a versatile option for various dishes. Positive reviews rave about the sauce’s taste, color, and level of heat, which doesn’t overpower the flavor.
It’s also praised for its versatility, being perfect for buffalo chicken wraps or salads, and can even be mixed into Ranch dressing for a kicked-up salad dressing.
While Moore Sauce Wing Buffalo may not be readily available in store chains, it can be conveniently purchased online.
Overall, customers are highly satisfied with this sauce, considering it the best wing sauce and seasoning available.
Best For: Those who enjoy tangy buffalo sauce with a nice kick, and are looking for a low-carb option for wings and shrimp.
What’s So Great
- Perfect balance of heat and flavor
- Versatile, great for buffalo chicken wraps or salads
- Can be mixed into Ranch dressing for a kicked-up salad dressing
Good to Know
- Not available in store chains, must be purchased online
8. Sweet Baby Ray’s Buffalo Wing
If you’re looking for a buffalo sauce that adds just the right amount of spice and rich garlic flavor to your wings, Sweet Baby Ray’s Buffalo Wing is the great store-bought choice.
This high-quality buffalo wing sauce comes in a pack of two 16 oz bottles, allowing you to make your own delicious wings at home.
Many customers rave about the flavor, describing it as amazing with the perfect amount of hotness and spice. They also mention that a little goes a long way, making it a cost-effective option.
However, there are concerns about the inclusion of propylene glycol as a preservative, which is a known carcinogen.
Some customers have expressed disappointment with this ingredient and the difficulty in returning the product.
Despite this, Sweet Baby Ray’s Buffalo Wing remains a popular choice for those seeking a flavorful buffalo sauce.
Best For: Wings enthusiasts who enjoy a flavorful buffalo sauce with a perfect balance of spice and garlic.
What’s So Great
- High-quality buffalo wing sauce with a delightful flavor
- A little goes a long way, making it cost-effective
- Allows you to make delicious wings at home
Good to Know
- Contains propylene glycol, a known carcinogen, which raises concerns for some customers
9. Hot Ones Buffalo Sauce
The Hot Ones Buffalo Sauce is the top store-bought choice for those seeking a rich and tangy buffalo sauce made with all-natural ingredients and a perfect heat-to-taste ratio.
This small batch production sauce combines mild Cayenne peppers, distilled vinegar, and real butter to create a flavor profile that’s both delicious and versatile.
With a heat level of 2/10, it provides just the right amount of kick without overpowering your taste buds.
The sauce can be used directly on hot wings or as a condiment for various dishes such as ribs, chicken, and enchiladas.
Its thick consistency, thanks to the real butter used, ensures that it stays put on your food.
While some customers have expressed concerns about the small bottle size and the price, the overall recommendation is to try this sauce for its great flavor, heat, and versatility.
Best For: Those who enjoy a tangy buffalo sauce with a mild heat level and a versatile flavor profile.
What’s So Great
- Rich and tangy flavor combination of mild Cayenne peppers, vinegar, and real butter
- Can be used directly on hot wings or as a condiment for various dishes
- Thick consistency ensures the sauce stays put on your food
Good to Know
- Small bottle size may not be sufficient for some customers
10. Wing Time Buffalo Wing Sauce
For those seeking a buffalo wing sauce that strikes the perfect balance between heat and flavor, Wing Time Buffalo Wing Sauce is the ideal store-bought choice.
This medium heat sauce offers plenty of kick without overpowering your taste buds. The sauce is packaged well, ensuring that it arrives intact and ready to use.
Wing Time Buffalo Wing Sauce has garnered positive reviews from customers who appreciate its thick and creamy texture, which enhances the flavor of their dishes. It’s highly recommended for wings, buffalo chicken wraps, and salads.
Moreover, Wing Time has been a trusted brand for 30 years, making it a go-to choice for long-time customers. Its versatility also sets it apart, as it can be used on various dishes, not just wings.
While some customers have experienced packaging issues when ordering from Amazon, Wing Time Buffalo Wing Sauce remains a top contender for the best buffalo wing sauce available.
Best For: Those who enjoy medium heat buffalo wing sauce with a perfect blend of taste and heat.
What’s So Great
- A favorite sauce with a thick and creamy texture
- Versatile and can be used on various dishes
- Highly recommended for wings, buffalo chicken wraps, and salads
Good to Know
- Some customers have experienced packaging issues when ordering from Amazon
Frequently Asked Questions
Can buffalo sauce be used for other dishes besides chicken wings?
Buffalo sauce isn’t just for chicken wings. It can be used in a variety of dishes to add a spicy kick.
For example, you can use buffalo sauce to make buffalo cauliflower bites, where the cauliflower is coated in the sauce and baked until crispy.
It also pairs well with burgers, giving them a tangy flavor.
Additionally, you can drizzle buffalo sauce on top of pizzas or even use it as a sauce for tacos, adding a unique twist to your favorite dishes.
What is the difference between buffalo sauce and hot sauce?
When comparing buffalo sauce and hot sauce, the main difference lies in the flavor. Buffalo sauce has a tangy and buttery taste, whereas hot sauce is more about the heat.
Traditional buffalo sauce typically consists of hot sauce, melted butter, and vinegar. If you want to make your own homemade buffalo sauce, simply combine these ingredients and adjust the spicy heat levels to your liking.
It’s worth noting that regional variations of buffalo sauce exist, each with their own unique twist.
Are there any store-bought buffalo sauces that are gluten-free?
Looking for gluten-free options in store-bought buffalo sauce?
There are several popular brands that offer gluten-free varieties, such as Frank’s RedHot and Tessemae’s.
If you prefer homemade alternatives, you can easily make your own gluten-free buffalo sauce using ingredients like hot sauce, butter, and spices.
Additionally, some brands also offer vegan options for those following a plant-based diet.
Whether you like it spicy or mild, there are plenty of gluten-free buffalo sauce options to choose from.
Can buffalo sauce be stored in the refrigerator after opening?
After opening, buffalo sauce can be stored in the refrigerator to prolong its shelf life.
The best way to store buffalo sauce is to keep it in an airtight container to prevent air and moisture from affecting its quality.
It’s important to check the expiration date of the sauce and discard it if it has passed.
Are there any low-sodium options available for store-bought buffalo sauce?
Looking for low-sodium options for buffalo sauce? You’ll be glad to know that there are plenty of choices available!
From popular brands to homemade recipes, you can find low-fat alternatives that still pack a spicy punch.
These sauces not only satisfy your cravings but also offer health benefits with their reduced sodium content.
