How to Pick Good Store-Bought Sourdough Bread

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. See our disclosure policy.

Choosing the best sourdough bread for your needs is a rewarding endeavor that combines sensory evaluation, understanding of ingredients, and your personal health goals.

Unlike commercial breads, sourdough often contains fewer preservatives and additives, as it relies on a natural fermentation process to rise.

How to Pick Good Store-Bought Sourdough Bread 0

However, not all store-bought sourdough breads are created equal. Here’s how to pick the best one for you.

1. Understanding Your Needs
First and foremost, you need to consider why you’re opting for sourdough. Are you looking for a bread that’s easier to digest, are you interested in the distinct tangy flavor, or are you simply trying to avoid additives that are found in many commercial breads? Your priorities will help guide your selection.

2. Ingredients List
Sourdough should ideally have a simple list of ingredients—flour, water, salt, and the natural yeasts and bacteria that form the starter culture. Be cautious of breads that have a long list of additives, preservatives, or added sugars. Also, consider the type of flour used. If you’re gluten-sensitive, you may want a bread made from lower-gluten grains like spelled or rye, although note that sourdough is not gluten-free unless explicitly stated.

3. Crust and Color
A good sourdough bread often has a hard, crispy crust. However, the thickness and texture of the crust can vary depending on your preference. The color of the crust can also be indicative of the baking process; a deep brown color suggests a longer baking time, which can deepen the flavors. Don’t shy away from darker crusts unless you prefer a milder flavor profile.

4. Smell
Sourdough has a distinctive tangy smell due to its fermentation process. A good sourdough should smell slightly acidic but not overpowering. If a loaf smells musty or off, it’s likely not fresh or may be improperly fermented.

5. Crumb
The interior of the bread, or the crumb, should be moist but not gummy. Small to medium-sized air pockets indicate a well-fermented dough. Too many large holes could mean the dough was over-fermented or wasn’t properly kneaded. While traditionally, sourdough does have a denser structure compared to yeasted breads; it shouldn’t feel like a brick; rather, it should offer a pleasant chew.

6. Flavor
The perfect sourdough should be balanced in flavor: not too sour, but with a distinct tang that differentiates it from regular bread. If possible, sample before you buy. Some bakeries offer tasting slices, which can be incredibly helpful.

7. Special Needs and Preferences
If you have dietary restrictions or health considerations, look for specialized options. Some bakeries make whole-grain sourdough, which offers more fiber and nutrients. There are also options that incorporate seeds like sunflower, flax, or sesame, adding extra texture and nutritional benefits.

How is Sourdough Bread Different from Other Breads?

Sourdough bread stands apart from other types of bread in several ways:

1. Natural Fermentation: Unlike breads made with commercial yeast, sourdough relies on a natural fermentation process. A mixture of flour and water cultivate wild yeast and lactic acid bacteria, giving the bread its characteristic tang and better digestibility.

2. Flavor Profile: The fermentation process imbues sourdough with a unique blend of flavors—from sour to nutty—that is hard to replicate in yeasted breads.

3. Nutritional Profile: The lactic acid bacteria present in sourdough can make certain nutrients more bioavailable and decrease the bread’s glycemic index.

4. Shelf Life: Thanks to its acidity, sourdough tends to have a longer shelf life compared to most yeasted breads.

5. Textural Qualities: The fermentation also impacts the texture, yielding a chewier crumb and a crustier exterior.

Each of these aspects contributes to making sourdough a distinct and increasingly popular choice among bread lovers.

What are the Benefits of Eating Sourdough Bread?


Sourdough bread has been enjoyed for thousands of years and is known for its distinct tangy flavor.

Beyond its taste, it also offers a variety of health and nutritional benefits that set it apart from most commercially produced breads.

Here’s a closer look at some of those advantages:

1. Easier to Digest
The natural fermentation process involved in making sourdough helps to break down some of the gluten in the wheat, making it easier to digest for some people. The lactic acid bacteria in the sourdough can also help with the digestion of the bread itself, although it’s worth noting that sourdough is not suitable for those with celiac disease or severe gluten intolerance.

2. Lower Glycemic Index
Compared to many other breads, sourdough typically has a lower glycemic index (GI). This means that it releases energy more slowly and doesn’t cause a rapid spike in blood sugar levels. This can be particularly beneficial for people with diabetes or for those watching their sugar intake.

3. Rich in Nutrients
The fermentation process not only breaks down gluten but also aids in the breakdown of phytic acid, a substance found in grains that can inhibit the absorption of minerals like iron, zinc, and magnesium. As a result, the minerals in sourdough bread are more readily available for absorption by the body.

4. Better Microbiome Health
The lactic acid bacteria formed during the fermentation process are probiotics, which are good for your gut health. While most of these bacteria don’t survive the baking process, the lactic acid they produce can help create an environment in the gut that supports the growth of beneficial bacteria.

5. Longer Shelf Life
The natural acidity of sourdough helps to deter the growth of mold, giving this bread a longer shelf life compared to other types of bread without the need for preservatives.

6. No Need for Additives
True sourdough requires just a few basic ingredients: water, flour, salt, and the naturally occurring yeast and bacteria for fermentation. This simplicity often makes it a healthier choice, free from the preservatives and additives that are commonly found in commercial breads.

7. Whole Grain Options
While sourdough can be made with white flour, it is also often made with whole grains. Whole grain sourdough combines the benefits of sourdough with those of whole grains, which are rich in fiber and other nutrients.

8. Unique Flavor and Texture
Beyond the health benefits, the taste and texture of sourdough are unique and loved by many. The crusty exterior and soft, chewy interior make for a satisfying eating experience, and the complexity of flavors resulting from the fermentation process is unlike any other bread.

How to Pick Store-Bought Sourdough Bread?


We touched upon this earlier, but given its importance, it’s worth revisiting with a more focused approach.

Here are some specific tips for picking the right loaf:

1. Inspect the Loaf: Quality sourdough often has a darker crust with some cracks. These traits often indicate proper fermentation and baking.

2. Smell the Bread: A good sourdough will have a slightly sour but pleasing aroma. This is a sign of a well-fermented loaf.

3. The “Hollow” Test: Tap the bottom of the loaf. If it sounds hollow, it’s usually a sign of a well-baked loaf.

4. Label-Reading: Aside from ingredients, look for indications that the bread is artisanal or slow-fermented, as these are usually signs of higher quality.

5. Ask for Recommendations: Don’t hesitate to ask for staff recommendations when buying from a bakery or specialty store. They can guide you toward a loaf that meets your preferences in terms of flavor, texture, and dietary needs.

6. Consider the Slicing Option: Some people prefer buying their sourdough unsliced to preserve its freshness, while others might find pre-sliced loaves more convenient. Choose based on your lifestyle and needs.


Sourdough bread is a fantastic culinary creation that marries the complexity of flavor with a host of health benefits.

While nothing can quite beat a loaf of homemade sourdough, store-bought options have come a long way and offer a convenient alternative for those strapped for time or new to the sourdough world.

When picking a loaf off the shelf, consider factors like ingredients, texture, and your specific needs to make an informed choice.

With the detailed list of our top 10 choices, you will have an excellent starting point for venturing into the tasty world of sourdough bread.

Whether you enjoy it as a base for hearty sandwiches, an accompaniment to soups, or as a stand-alone treat with a pat of butter, sourdough bread is a versatile staple that can elevate your meals and benefit your health.

So, the next time you find yourself wandering the bread aisle of your local grocery store, you’ll be well-equipped to make a choice that’s not just good but also good for you.

Happy eating!

Leave a Comment