The Best Store-Bought Bagels by Favorite Brands at Grocery Store

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. See our disclosure policy.

If you think finding the best store-bought bagel brand is an impossible task, think again. There’s a variety of bagel brands and flavors out there available at grocery stores might just surprise you.

But which one truly stands out above the rest? Well, let’s just say that one of these bagels might just change your breakfast game forever.

The 10 Best Store Bought Bagels That Will Elevate Your Breakfast Game 0

So, are you ready to discover the ultimate store-bought bagels that will make your mornings even better?

Key Takeaways

  • Thomas Plain Bagels offer a versatile, healthy, and fresh option without artificial sweeteners.
  • Amazon Fresh Everything Bagels provide a convenient, affordable, and flavorful breakfast choice loved by both kids and adults.
  • Dave’s Killer Bread Bagels stand out for their high protein, organic ingredients, and delicious flavors, ideal for nutritious meals.
  • Specialty bagels like Dave’s Killer Bread Plain Awesome Bagels offer a nutritious, tasty option with super grains and convenience.

Which is The 10 Best Grocery Store Bagel Brands You Can Buy?

When it comes to the best store-bought bagel brands, you’ll want to contemplate the Thomas Plain Bagels for a classic option.

If you prefer a smaller size, the Thomas Plain Mini Bagels Pre-Sliced could be a convenient choice.

For those looking for a little more flavor, the Amazon Fresh Brand Everything Pre-Sliced Bagels might be worth a try.

1. Thomas Plain Bagels

The 10 Best Store Bought Bagels That Will Elevate Your Breakfast Game 1

Buy It

For bagel enthusiasts seeking a reliably delicious and traditional option, the Thomas Plain Bagels stand out as the best store-bought choice.

These soft and crunchy bagels offer a perfect balance of textures – crunchy on the outside and soft & chewy inside when toasted.

With no high-fructose corn syrup or artificial sweeteners, these bagels pack a good punch of 9g protein and 2g fiber per serving, making them a satisfying choice.

Customer reviews highlight that they stay soft and fresh in the fridge, although they may need a bit longer toasting than sliced bread.

Whether paired with cream cheese, butter, or whipped cream cheese, these bagels are versatile and perfect for sandwiches, mini pizzas, or snacks.

Additionally, they freeze well, maintaining their freshness for weeks, making them a convenient and tasty option for breakfast or any time of the day.

Best For: Those looking for a versatile and satisfying option for breakfast or snacks.

What’s So Great

  • Soft and crunchy texture
  • No high-fructose corn syrup or artificial sweeteners
  • Good source of protein and fiber

Good to Know

  • May require longer toasting compared to sliced bread

2. Thomas Plain Mini Bagels Pre-Sliced

The 10 Best Store Bought Bagels That Will Elevate Your Breakfast Game 2

Buy It

With its convenient pre-sliced feature and delectable taste, Thomas Plain Mini Bagels are the top choice for those seeking a quick and satisfying breakfast or snack option.

These 15 oz bags of 10 pre-sliced mini bagels offer a crispy exterior and a soft interior when lightly toasted.

Made without high fructose corn syrup or artificial sweeteners, they’re perfect for breakfast sandwiches, snacking, or pairing with cream cheese.

Customer reviews highlight the convenience of the pre-sliced design, suggesting they’re best enjoyed heated before spreading cream cheese or with flavorful toppings like chive/onion cream cheese.

The size is ideal for breakfast accompaniments like eggs, bacon, or ham, catering well to individuals who prefer smaller portions.

Highly recommended for their versatility, these mini bagels can even be used to create mini pizzas, making them a practical choice for various occasions.

Best For: Individuals looking for a convenient and versatile breakfast or snack option with pre-sliced mini bagels.

What’s So Great

  • Convenient pre-sliced design
  • Versatile usage for various toppings or fillings
  • Suitable for those who prefer smaller portions

Good to Know

  • May not be satisfying for those looking for a larger bagel size

3. Amazon Fresh Brand Plain Pre Sliced Bagels

The 10 Best Store Bought Bagels That Will Elevate Your Breakfast Game 3

Buy It

The Amazon Fresh Brand Plain Pre-Sliced Bagels stand out as an excellent choice for budget-conscious individuals seeking a convenient and tasty breakfast option.

This 21-ounce bag of 6 plain bagels offers a high-quality food experience at an affordable price point.

While some customers praise the bagels for their chewy texture and good flavor, there are mixed opinions on pricing and value due to reported price fluctuations.

Positive reviews highlight the enjoyable taste and texture when toasted, but complaints about uneven slicing and firmness exist. Despite these issues, some consumers express plans to repurchase, indicating potential for improvement.

Overall, the Amazon Fresh bagels present a reasonably priced option with room for enhancement in slicing consistency.

Best For: Budget-conscious individuals seeking a convenient and tasty breakfast option.

What’s So Great

  • Chewy texture and good flavor
  • High-quality food at an affordable price
  • Positive reviews on taste and texture when toasted

Good to Know

  • Price fluctuations mentioned

4. Dave’s Killer Bread Plain Awesome Bagels

The 10 Best Store Bought Bagels That Will Elevate Your Breakfast Game 4

Buy It

A standout feature of Dave’s Killer Bread Plain Awesome Bagels is the incorporation of 5 super grains and 13 grams of whole grains per serving, making them a top choice for health-conscious consumers seeking a nutrient-rich breakfast option.

These bagels aren’t only packed with wholesome ingredients but also come pre-sliced for added convenience.

Certified USDA Organic and Non GMO Project Verified, they meet high-quality standards. While some customers find them a bit pricey, the praise for their taste and nutritional value is consistent.

It’s worth noting that some have mentioned a slight bitterness, especially when eaten plain, but this can easily be masked with cream cheese.

Overall, Dave’s Killer Bread Plain Awesome Bagels offer a delicious and healthy option for your morning routine.

Best For: Health-conscious consumers looking for a nutrient-rich and convenient breakfast option.

What’s So Great

  • Certified USDA Organic and Non GMO Project Verified
  • Contains 5 super grains and 13 grams of whole grains per serving
  • Pre-sliced for added convenience

Good to Know

  • Some customers find the bagels a bit pricey

5. Amazon Fresh Brand Everything Pre Sliced Bagels

The 10 Best Store Bought Bagels That Will Elevate Your Breakfast Game 5

Buy It

Indulge in Amazon Fresh Brand Everything Pre-Sliced Bagels, a savory delight that caters to those seeking a flavorful and convenient breakfast option.

These 21-ounce bagels come pre-sliced, making them ideal for quick mornings. Certified Kosher and made with wheat, they offer a high-quality breakfast choice at an affordable price.

Customer reviews praise their great taste and value for money, with many noting their delicious flavor that exceeded expectations. While some mention a slightly higher sodium content, overall, these bagels are enjoyed by both kids and adults.

Perfect for toasting or enjoying straight from the bag, these bagels offer a balance of flavor, texture, and softness. However, compared to other brands, opinions are mixed, with some finding them too chewy and dense while others appreciate their freshness and taste.

Best For: Those looking for a quick and delicious breakfast option that offers great taste and value for money.

What’s So Great

  • Convenient pre-sliced bagels ideal for quick mornings
  • High-quality and affordable breakfast choice
  • Enjoyed by both kids and adults with perfect flavor, texture, and softness

Good to Know

  • Some may find the bagels too chewy and dense

6. Daves Killer Bread Organic Everything Bagels

The 10 Best Store Bought Bagels That Will Elevate Your Breakfast Game 6

Buy It

When seeking store-bought bagels that prioritize organic ingredients and robust flavor profiles, consider Daves Killer Bread Organic Everything Bagels.

These 16.75 oz pre-sliced bagels are Certified USDA Organic and Non-GMO Project Verified, offering 26 grams of whole grains and 13 grams of protein per serving.

Topped with poppy seeds, sesame seeds, garlic, and onion, they provide a delightful crunch and savory aroma.

Customers praise their freshness, excellent taste, and filling nature, although some note a decrease in size and toppings over time. While the wheat-y aftertaste may not suit everyone, toasting enhances their unique texture and flavor.

Despite a higher price point, customers deem these bagels the best they’ve had, especially appreciating their suitability for dietary restrictions and the convenience of online ordering.

Best For: Those looking for organic, protein-packed bagels with a variety of whole grains and a robust flavor profile.

What’s So Great

  • Certified USDA Organic and Non-GMO Project Verified
  • High in whole grains and protein
  • Topped with a delightful mix of poppy seeds, sesame seeds, garlic, and onion

Good to Know

  • Some customers find the bagels smaller with less toppings over time

7. Whole Foods Market Plain Bagel

The 10 Best Store Bought Bagels That Will Elevate Your Breakfast Game 7

Buy It

For those seeking a wholesome and flavorful option among store-bought bagels, the Whole Foods Market Plain Bagel stands out as a reliable choice with its absence of hydrogenated fats, high-fructose corn syrup, bleached, or bromated flours.

While some customers praise the Blueberry bagels for their generous amount of blueberries and convenience for kids’ breakfast or snacks, others have noted that the flavor could be improved.

The bagels are appreciated for their good price and shelf life, being moist and flavorful even without toasting. However, there are mixed reviews regarding the density, quick molding, and best storage practices.

Some consumers suggest keeping them in the fridge or using lock n lock containers to maintain freshness.

Overall, the Whole Foods Market Plain Bagel is recommended as a convenient option, though it may not stand out as exceptional.

Best For: Families looking for a convenient and kid-friendly breakfast or snack option with decent shelf life.

What’s So Great

  • Generous amount of blueberries in the Blueberry bagels
  • Good price point and shelf life
  • Moist and flavorful, can be enjoyed without toasting

Good to Know

  • Some customers find the flavor lacking

8. Thomas Cinnamon Raisin Bagels

The 10 Best Store Bought Bagels That Will Elevate Your Breakfast Game 8

Buy It

With a perfect blend of cinnamon and raisins, Thomas Cinnamon Raisin Bagels are a delightful choice for those seeking a flavorful and protein-rich snack or meal option.

These bagels offer a satisfying crunch on the outside while maintaining a soft and chewy texture inside, especially when lightly toasted.

With 0g trans-fat and being cholesterol-free, they’re a healthier alternative. Each serving packs 9g of protein and 3g of fiber, making them a substantial choice to keep you full and energized.

Customer reviews rave about the delicious combination of cinnamon and raisins, suggesting pairing them with strawberry cream cheese for a delightful treat.

Whether you enjoy them on their own or as a base for sandwiches or mini pizzas, Thomas Cinnamon Raisin Bagels are sure to please your taste buds.

Best For: Those who enjoy a flavorful and protein-rich snack or meal option with a satisfying crunch and soft, chewy texture.

What’s So Great

  • Delicious combination of cinnamon and raisins
  • High protein content
  • Versatile for various meal options

Good to Know

  • May not be suitable for those with cinnamon or raisin allergies

9. Franz Soft Plain Bagels

The 10 Best Store Bought Bagels That Will Elevate Your Breakfast Game 9

Buy It

If you seek a soft, flavorful bagel option that caters to those craving a low-fat, high-protein breakfast or snack, Franz Soft Plain Bagels stand out as the best choice in the domain of store-bought bagels.

These bagels come in a 6ct pack, offering a low-fat energy boost with 7 grams of protein per bagel. They’re soft, sliced for convenience, and free from artificial colors, high fructose corn syrup, and trans fat.

While some customers found them smaller than expected, overall feedback praises their softness and flavor. The Onion flavor, in particular, receives accolades for its great taste and freshness.

Despite mixed opinions on size and consistency, most customers recommend Franz Soft Plain Bagels for their quality and taste, making them a popular choice for regular purchases.

Best For: Individuals seeking a low-fat, high-protein breakfast or snack option that’s soft and flavorful.

What’s So Great

  • Low fat option with 7 grams of protein per bagel
  • Soft and sliced for convenience
  • Free from artificial colors, high fructose corn syrup, and trans fat

Good to Know

  • Some customers found the bagels smaller than expected

10. Thomas’ Everything Bagels Pre-Sliced

The 10 Best Store Bought Bagels That Will Elevate Your Breakfast Game 10

Buy It

Indulge in the convenience and delectable flavor of Thomas’ Everything Bagels Pre-Sliced, perfect for those seeking a satisfying breakfast or snack option without compromising on taste or quality.

These bagels offer a delightful crunch on the outside while remaining soft inside when toasted, creating a texture that’s both satisfying and delicious.

The flavorful blend of spices in the everything seasoning adds a tasty twist to each bite, making them a popular choice among bagel enthusiasts.

Customers rave about the good size and texture of these bagels, noting their fresh yet chewy consistency.

Whether you enjoy them plain, with cream cheese, or as a base for breakfast sandwiches or pizza bagels, Thomas’ Everything Bagels Pre-Sliced are a versatile and tasty option for any time of the day.

Best For: Those looking for a flavorful and versatile breakfast or snack option with a satisfying crunch and soft texture.

What’s So Great

  • Convenient pre-sliced bagels
  • Delicious and flavorful everything seasoning
  • Suitable for various meal options

Good to Know

  • May be pricier than other bagel options

Frequently Asked Questions

How do store-bought bagels compare in terms of freshness and taste to freshly baked bagels from a bakery?

When you compare store-bought bagels to freshly baked ones from a bakery, the flavor may lack a bit and the texture mightn’t be as chewy. Shelf life and ingredient lists are longer on store-bought options, but they win on convenience and price point. Brand reputation and customer reviews vary, so it’s wise to check those out.

Packaging design is more uniform, but nutritional value can sometimes be questionable.

Are store-bought bagels typically made with artificial preservatives or additives?

When you examine the ingredient list of store-bought bagels, you might find artificial preservatives or additives that extend their shelf life but could impact their nutritional value.

These additives can affect the texture of the bagels, making them different from freshly baked ones.

Consider this when comparing prices, as the convenience of store-bought bagels comes with trade-offs in ingredients and taste.

What are some common allergens found in store-bought bagels?

Common allergens frequently found in store-bought bagels include wheat, soy, and sesame seeds. Allergen labeling is essential for those with dietary restrictions. Cross-contamination poses risks, so strict food safety measures are necessary.

Labeling laws mandate clear allergen information. Traceability guarantees product quality and safety. Allergen testing and supplier audits are indispensable for effective allergen management.

Quality control is essential to prevent allergen-related issues and maintain consumer trust.

Can store-bought bagels be frozen and reheated successfully without losing their quality?

Yes, store-bought bagels can be frozen and reheated successfully without losing their quality. When freezing bagels, make sure they’re well-sealed to prevent freezer burn. Reheating methods like toasting or microwaving can help revive their freshness. Opt for preservative-free options for a healthier choice.

While the texture may slightly change after freezing, certain brands like XYZ have bagels that hold up well. Experiment with different methods to find what works best for you.

Are there any store-bought bagel brands that specialize in unique flavor options or dietary restrictions, such as gluten-free or vegan?

When it comes to store-bought bagels, you’ll find various options to cater to different preferences. Flavor options range from classic to exotic, with some brands offering unique toppings and specialty ingredients.

Gluten-free brands guarantee those with dietary restrictions can still enjoy a tasty bagel, while vegan varieties cater to plant-based diets.

Whether you’re a fan of traditional flavors or looking for something more adventurous, there are store-bought bagel brands that suit your needs.

Leave a Comment